The World Bank’s external panel of experts in their final report has not made any final assessment of the probe into the Padma Bridge corruption conspiracy, saying it will have to wait until the end of the Anti-Corruption Commission’s investigation to say whether it was “full and fair.”
“A final assessment of the adequacy of the ACC’s investigative activities should be done at the end of the ACC investigation,” the panel said in its final report to the World Bank, a copy of which was obtained by the Dhaka Tribune on Tuesday.
The report reads: “The panel cannot conclude that the activity of the ACC constitutes a full and fair investigation.”
The World Bank appointed a three-member panel of experts, headed by Luis Moreno-Ocampo, following an allegation of “criminal conspiracy” over the country’s largest infrastructure project.
After a long debate over the issue, Bangladesh finally backed out of the proposed financing by the World Bank, which had pledged to finance $1.2bn for the $2.9bn project.
However, the panel's final report said there were no legal reasons to exclude the name of the former communications minister, Syed Abul Hossain, from the initial list of persons under investigation
After receiving the information from the World Bank, the ACC had confirmed there was sufficient evidence to launch a formal investigation into the allegations of a criminal conspiracy in relation to the selection of the construction supervision consultant for the bridge project.
To this end, ACC issued a first information report against seven individuals identified by information provided to the ACC as being involved in the conspiracy.
“They were suspected of having attempted to obtain financial gains for themselves and others by favouring SNC Lavalin and its partners in the tender process,” said the report.
Johannes Zutt, the new WB country director, handed over the panel’s final report to the finance minister on June 11.The panel objected to the ACC’s decision to drop the name of the former communications minister from the charge sheet.
ACC Chairman Ghulam Rahman defended their decision, saying the commission cannot accuse the former communications minister just because the World Bank’s external panel suggested it in their report.
“Evidence and witnesses must be available to accuse a person,” he told journalists at the finance ministry yesterday, after submitting an ACC response to Finance Minister AMA Muhith on the panel report.
“They (WB) have a problem with only one person,” the ACC chairman told the Dhaka Tribune. “In our reply, we said, if needed, we will try to find out whether the former communication minister had any connection to the conspiracy. If anyone is found involved with the scam, we will surely take legal action against them.”
He said the commission’s latest recommendations were similar to its previous proposals.
Ghulam stated that the ACC was still investigating the allegation. “We will make accusations and take legal actions against any individual if their involvement is ascertained through our investigation.”
Finance Minister AMA Muhith on Monday said an official response to the WB panel report would be provided this week.



