The High Court is set to resume tomorrow the hearing on a petition that challenges the constitutional provision of state religion – after nearly five years of its adjournment.
The petition was filed in 1988 by 15 eminent citizens, including former judges and academicians, many of whom are now dead.
The matter was absent from discussion tables until August 1 last year when Supreme Court lawyer Somendra Nath Goswami filed another petition with the High Court challenging the state religion provision as it was against the basic secular structure of the state.
He also sought justification of retaining the clause even though the government had restored secularism through the 15th Amendment to the Constitution in 2011. The petition was heard on August 30 and rejected by the court on September 7 last year.
On February 29, Chief Justice Surendra Kumar Sinha formed a new three-member bench to hear the 1988 petition following a prayer submitted on behalf of the petitioners. The new bench led by Justice Naima Haider also withdrew a previous order to hear opinions from over a dozen amici curiae.
Irked over the announcement of a fresh hearing, radical Islamist groups and leaders have warned that they would paralyse the country if the provision was dropped. They have been staging demonstrations in Dhaka and elsewhere, and are campaigning on social media and blogs to drum up support against the move.
The groups include Jamaat-e-Islami, Qawmi madrasa-based radical platform Hefazat-e-Islam, which emerged in 2013 by placing 13-point demands including formulation of anti-blasphemy law and a ban on free mixing of men and women, and other like-minded Islamist groups including its key component Islami Oikyo Jote.
Hefazat yesterday held protest processions in Dhaka, Chittagong and some other places. Leaders and activists of Jamaat and Islami Chhatra Shibir participated in the demonstrations too.
The Islamist leaders claim that the non-Muslims of the country are conspiring to scrap the state religion provision. They have also criticised the BNP and former president HM Ershad, who introduced the state religion provision, for keeping mum on the matter.
On the other hand, secularists have welcomed the court’s announcement as they think the existence of secularism and state religion in the constitution is contradictory. They have also urged the government to impose again the ban on religion-based politics as was in the first constitution of 1972.
They think that the recognition of Islam as state religion and the lifting of a ban on religion-based politics had given rise to radicalism and militant activities in the country.
Since 2013, Islamist militants carried out dozens of fatal attacks on secularists, religious minorities and Christian foreigners, shrines and mosques, prompting the government to declare zero-tolerance against all forms of religious extremism.
The Awami League-led government on June 30, 2011 reinstated secularism as one of the four pillars of the constitution but retained the state religion provision, and took no step to ban religion-based politics. The current government maintains that the co-existence of state religion and secularism is not contradictory as the constitution ensures equal rights for adherents of other religions too.
Before Ershad, former president and BNP founder Ziaur Rahman lifted the ban on religion-based politics, paving the way for Jamaat and other Islamist parties to resume politics.
Ershad, now the premier’s special envoy, while introducing the provision claimed that since Muslims had overwhelming majority, they would not be able to establish its identity of nationhood, independence and sovereignty without Islam as the state religion.
The government high-ups had also said that the move was initiated with a view to curbing the alarming growth of fundamentalism, with particular reference to the politics of Jamaat-e-Islami, known for its religious fanaticism.
But the move has apparently failed to achieve the goal.
Subrata Chowdhury, a lawyer representing the petitioners, said: “By making Islam the state religion, the then military government destroyed the basic character of our secular constitution.
“The minorities were relegated to second class citizens of the republic,” he told the AFP news agency recently.
The legal battle
After the passage of the Eighth Amendment Bill on June 7, 1988, 15 noted personalities filed a public interest litigation challenging the state religion provision.
They are Begum Sufia Kamal, former chief justice Kemal Uddin Hossain, Khan Sarwar Murshid, Prof Kabir Chowdhury, Prof Mosharraf Hossain, Maj Gen (retd) Chitta Ranjan Datta (Bir Uttam), Prof Serajul Islam Choudhury, Badruddin Umar, journalist Foyez Ahmed, Borhan Uddin Khan Jahangir, Prof Anisuzzaman, Justice Devesh Chandra Bhattacharjee, Justice KM Sobhan, Syed Istiaq Ahmed and Kalim Sharafi. Many of them are now dead.
The first hearing on the petition began on June 8, 2011 in response to a supplementary petition. A High Court bench issued a ruling upon the government as to why the provision should not be declared to have been made without lawful authority. The government has not responded yet.
The court also appointed 12 amici curiae on that day to give their opinions on the matter. On June 9, the court appointed two other lawyers as amici curiae.
On June 16, three of the amici curiae told the court that the issue should be left to parliament, which was then in session and a special committee was working to amend the constitution in light of the Supreme Court judgements.
The hearing continued for two days and adjourned until July 14. But it did not take place on that day.



