The proposed budget has limitations with regard to credibility for fiscal planning in many areas including source of financing, revenue income and expenditure, think tank Centre for Policy Dialogue observes.
“Budgeting in Bangladesh continues to lack benchmarks on progress, expansion and plans concerning various measures and initiatives from the earlier budget,” CPD distinguished fellow Debapriya Bhattacharya said in a post-budget reaction yesterday.
The CPD says the budget size of Tk2.95tn is not ambitious but the budgetary plan to finance it is worrisome.
The government set the target to finance the budget from domestic borrowings worth Tk565.23bn and external sources Tk301.34bn. “The budgetary plan is not in line with the actual achievement, which is concerning,” Debapriya said.
According to CPD’s projections, all major parameters of fiscal framework will need to register higher growth rates to attain the targets compared to those planned in the budget FY16 … “because the budget targets take revised budget figures for FY15 as its base which in reality will lesser.”
It observes that fiscal gap of revenue income continued to widen as it stood at 17.4% in FY15 from 15.4% in FY14. The new budget targets an additional Tk45,072 crore revenue with a 27.6% growth over revised of the outgoing fiscal year. “This is not realistic target in the light of our past experiences,” Debapriya said.
“To finance the budget, the government has increasingly become dependent on bank borrowing, which will affect credit flow to the private sector,” he added.
“The size of expenditure does not matter, but how the funds will be sourced matters.”
He said the budget mentioned almost $5bn worth of foreign assistance for financing the deficit, which means Bangladesh needs to use $2bn foreign aid more than it usually uses.
“But history says that Bangladesh always failed to use less than $3bn foreign aid. So the aim of financing 82.5% of incremental deficit using foreign sources cannot be sustainable in the long term.”
Debapriya strongly criticised setting aside Tk5,000 crore for recapitalising state-owned banks saying it is totally waste of public money and that this allocation is not a viable idea without going for necessary reforms in the banking sector.
The budget failed to give a picture on some measures, which was taken in FY15, including green and eco tax, district budget, and progress of digitised land survey were missing from the FY2016 budget while the Chittagong Hill Tracts (CHT) Affairs ministry was lagging in terms of budgetary expenditure, the CPD observes.
“Keeping silent regarding black money appears to be a continuation of earlier facilities to whiten black money,” Debapriya said.
On the other hand, the CPD has lauded budgetary allocations for infrastructure development, raising of tax at source for apparel sector and cutting corporate tax.
But it criticised the budget for ignoring health and education sectors.
It suggests to incorporate a matrix for future budgets, articulating the progress of key initiatives in the preceding budget, and a plan and timeline for key milestones to be achieved during the upcoming budget period.
Total allocation for agriculture and allied sectors continued to decrease. To ensure fair prices for agricultural commodities, the CPD has proposed setting up of a Permanent Agricultural Price Commission on an urgent basis to ensure incentive price for the producers while maintaining market stability.
With regard to taxation, the think tank lauded a number of good moves including raising the ceiling for personal income tax and taxing allowance of government officials but did not find it fair to set the minimum tax of Tk4,000 across all geographical locations.



