Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Asif Nazrul: Self-contradictory statements cast doubt on President's eligibility

  • President Shahabuddin says he has no official document of Hasina’s resignation
  • Asif Nazrul claims the President violated his oath regarding the resignation
Update : 21 Oct 2024, 07:47 PM

Law Adviser Asif Nazrul has said that the president's remarks concerning ousted Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina's resignation letter are not only misleading but also represent a serious breach of constitutional duty. 

He said that on August 5, the president himself mentioned in a speech that he had received and accepted the resignation letter of former prime minister Sheikh Hasina.

The law adviser said that now, if the president claims—nearly two and a half months later—that the former prime minister did not submit a resignation letter, this would be a form of self-contradiction. 

He further emphasized that through various actions, it has become clear to the entire nation that Hasina had indeed resigned, and the President had accepted it.

Dr Nazrul made these remarks on Monday while responding to questions from journalists at the Secretariat regarding the President’s statement.

Asif Nazrul further said: “It amounts to a violation of his oath because, in his speech to the nation on August 5 at 11:20pm, flanked by the chiefs of the three armed forces, he explicitly stated that ‘Sheikh Hasina has submitted her resignation letter to me,’ and he accepted it. Afterward, the Supreme Court’s Appellate Division was consulted to seek guidance on the next steps under Article 106 of the Constitution. The then chief justice and other judges provided an opinion.”

He continued: “The first line of that opinion was, ‘Since the prime minister has resigned under the current circumstances...’. Following the prime minister’s resignation and the dissolution of Parliament by the president, we sent a note from the Ministry’s office to the president, based on the opinion of the Appellate Division, regarding the formation of an interim government. The president reviewed and accepted this opinion. He then proceeded to form an interim government himself.”

He further remarked: “According to the Constitution of Bangladesh, if the President lacks mental or physical competence, or if he engages in serious misconduct, there is provision for action to be taken regarding his eligibility to remain in office.”

Nazrul added: “How can a person in the highest office, after announcing the resignation in front of the entire nation and seeking the opinion of the highest court, now claim otherwise? It is beyond my comprehension. There is no room for self-contradictory statements now.”

He said: "If you contradict something you have said yourself in front of the whole nation, then that is akin to misconduct. Then the question arises if he has the mental capacity to serve as the president. These questions may arise, he has created the scope for that."

He also said that if the president remains adamant about his statement, the advisory council of the interim government will discuss in a meeting whether Shahabuddin is qualified to remain in the position of president.

In response to the question of whether the resignation letter is with the government, Asif Nazrul clarified: “The resignation was supposed to be submitted to the President. It should be in the President’s office, and under the Constitution of Bangladesh, there is no room to raise this issue in court. If he now says there is no resignation letter, you should ask him what he did with it.”

In an exclusive interview with Matiur Rahman Chowdhury, Editor-in-Chief of the Daily Manab Zamin, President Mohammed Shahabuddin stated that he had heard of Sheikh Hasina’s resignation but had not received any official documents or evidence related to it. The interview was published last Saturday in the political magazine edition “Jonotar Chokh.”

Top Brokers