Judge stripped of judicial power over rape case observations
Dhaka Tribune
Tribune Report
Publish : 14 Nov 2021, 02:02 PMUpdate : 14 Nov 2021, 02:02 PM
Mosammat Kamrunnahar, the judge who observed in a verdict that police should not record a case 72 hours after rape, has been stripped of her ability to preside over any cases.
In a media statement on Sunday, the Supreme Court’s Special Officer Saifur Rahman said that Chief Justice Syed Mahmud Hossain took the decision in consultation with the senior judges of the top court.
A letter has been sent to the Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs from the Supreme Court at 9.30am on Sunday to temporarily revoke her criminal jurisdiction and to attach her to the Law and Justice Division of the ministry by withdrawing her from her current workplace, it said.
The move comes after Law Minister Anisul Huq described the observation made by the judge as totally illegal and unconstitutional before adding there is no time limit in the criminal justice system for recording a case against an offence.
Speaking to the media on Saturday, Huq, a criminal law expert, said he would write to the chief justice on the issue the next day.
Kamrunnahar, the judge of the Women and Children Repression Prevention Tribunal-7, on Thursday acquitted Shafat Ahmed, the son of one of the owners of Apan Jewellers , and four others of charges of raping two university students at a hotel in Dhaka’s Banani in 2017.
In her observation, the judge said that the investigating officer submitted a biased chargesheet and that medical reports of the victims did not find any signs of sexual violation.
"The victims came to the police 38 days after the incident, saying they had been raped. The investigating officer should have given the matter proper consideration,” said Kamrunnahar.
The investigation officer “wasted the people's time”, she said before instructing police not record rape cases if 72 hours have passed since the incident.
Legal experts and rights activists have severely criticized the observation, and said it was contradictory to the law and justice and that it would further encourage rapists
Judge stripped of judicial power over rape case observations
Mosammat Kamrunnahar, the judge who observed in a verdict that police should not record a case 72 hours after rape, has been stripped of her ability to preside over any cases.
In a media statement on Sunday, the Supreme Court’s Special Officer Saifur Rahman said that Chief Justice Syed Mahmud Hossain took the decision in consultation with the senior judges of the top court.
A letter has been sent to the Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs from the Supreme Court at 9.30am on Sunday to temporarily revoke her criminal jurisdiction and to attach her to the Law and Justice Division of the ministry by withdrawing her from her current workplace, it said.
The move comes after Law Minister Anisul Huq described the observation made by the judge as totally illegal and unconstitutional before adding there is no time limit in the criminal justice system for recording a case against an offence.
Also Read - Law minister: Govt to repeal law allowing rape victim’s character to be questioned
Speaking to the media on Saturday, Huq, a criminal law expert, said he would write to the chief justice on the issue the next day.
Kamrunnahar, the judge of the Women and Children Repression Prevention Tribunal-7, on Thursday acquitted Shafat Ahmed, the son of one of the owners of Apan Jewellers , and four others of charges of raping two university students at a hotel in Dhaka’s Banani in 2017.
In her observation, the judge said that the investigating officer submitted a biased chargesheet and that medical reports of the victims did not find any signs of sexual violation.
"The victims came to the police 38 days after the incident, saying they had been raped. The investigating officer should have given the matter proper consideration,” said Kamrunnahar.
Also Read - Is rape legal after 72 hours?
The investigation officer “wasted the people's time”, she said before instructing police not record rape cases if 72 hours have passed since the incident.
Legal experts and rights activists have severely criticized the observation, and said it was contradictory to the law and justice and that it would further encourage rapists