Reliable Brokers
Online Investing
Alerts & Analysis
Easy Trading

Dengue death toll: Why official tally too low?

Lengthy procedure to ascertain death cause blamed

Update : 07 Aug 2019, 01:20 AM

People across Bangladesh are living in panic due to the ongoing dengue outbreak while rumours run rife that the government is keeping the dengue death tally low to protect its image.

Authorities, however, brushed off the rumours, saying it takes a lot of time to run tests and confirm that a person has actually died from the mosquito-borne disease.

According to the Health Emergency Operation Centre and Control Room of the Directorate General of Health Services (DGHS), the official death toll was 23 until Tuesday.

The unofficial tally reported by the mass media put the death toll over 60, including seven who died in Dhaka, Dinajpur and Rangpur between Monday night and Tuesday.

Officials, however, are not turning down the number of deaths reported by the media, saying these reports will help them to identify the deceased and the causes of death more efficiently.

But the official death toll will be updated only after seeing the results of their tests, they said.

Between January 1 and Tuesday, a total of 29,912 people were identified as dengue patients across the country, according to the DGHS. Of them, 2,348 were identified and admitted to hospitals between Monday and 8am on Tuesday.

Also, 7,968 are currently undergoing treatment in different hospitals countrywide.

Asking about the varying death tolls, DGHC control room Assistant Director Dr Ayesha Akhter said they are not authorized to update the number on their own. “We only update the death toll after the Institute of Epidemiology, Disease Control and Research (IEDCR) confirms.”

Media reports have claimed that one of the main reasons behind the delay in updating the tally is that hospitals are not properly submitting to IEDCR the samples and documents regarding the dengue patients who died.

DGHS Deputy Director (hospital 2) Dr Mohammed Eunus Ali said they have only verbally informed all public and private hospitals to submit the necessary samples and documents. “But we have not received any complaint from IEDCR in this regard.”

IEDCR Director Dr Meerjadi Sabrina Flora also confirmed that they were receiving everything necessary from the hospitals in Dhaka city. “But it becomes difficult to collect the samples on time if anyone dies outside Dhaka.”

Dhaka Tribune could not reach Dr Aminul Hasan, the line director of the DGHS Hospital Wing, as he is currently in Saudi Arabia to perform the Hajj.

What IEDCR says

IEDCR Director Dr Meerjadi told Dhaka Tribune that it is IEDCR's duty to ensure the dengue death toll. “We do not reject the numbers the mass media is reporting, but we cannot comment on that without going through the necessary tests.”

She said they follow a three-step procedure to confirm that the deaths were actually caused by dengue. “First, we collect all samples from a dead dengue patient to conduct the polymerase chain reaction or PCR test, which allows us to confirm the DNA or strain of the dengue virus.

“Second, we collect the deceased’s medical records, including the documents showing where they took the first test to identify dengue infection.”

She added: “If the patient dies at the hospital where he or she was admitted first, it becomes easier to collect the medical history. But if they go through treatment in several hospitals, the procedure gets lengthier.”

Third, Dr Meerjadi said, they interview the relatives who stayed mostly with the deceased patient during the treatment.

“Because of the current crisis, we are breaking our protocol and contacting the deceased’s family sometime within three days, while the standard procedure says they should be contacted three months after the patient’s death, allowing them to come to terms with their loss.”

She added: “It is crucial to properly complete the procedure. Because the medical history may indicate that the patient died from dengue. But, in several cases, PCR test confirmed that the patients had died from some other disease.” 

Before Tuesday, the dengue death toll according to DGHS was 18, which the IEDCR had confirmed in line with the three-step procedure, according to Dr Meerjadi.

She said they received samples and documents of 32 deceased patients since the dengue outbreak became worse.

“We are yet to complete the procedure in all 32 cases. But, of the remaining 14, we also found some patients who did not die from dengue,” she added.

7 more dead

Seven more dengue patients died in Dhaka, Rangpur and Dinajpur between Monday night and Tuesday.

In the capital, a woman named Hafsa Begum Lipi died while undergoing treatment at the Anwer Khan Modern Hospital on Monday night, confirmed the hospital’s Director Jasimuddin Khan.

Hafsa was an Italian expatriate, who returned to Bangladesh with her husband and children three weeks ago.

Another patient,  Md Hanif, 42, passed away around 2am on Tuesday at the Mugda Medical College and Hospital, said the hospital’s Director Dr Amin Ahmed Khan.

Three more people also fell prey to the dengue virus at the Dhaka Medical College Hospital (DMCH) on Tuesday, confirmed the hospital’s Assistant Director Dr Nasiruddin. As of now, 18 dengue patients have died at DMCH.

Monowara Begum, 75, of Chandpur, who was admitted to DMCH on Saturday, died around 4am.

Amjad Mondol, 52, of Manikganj, also died of the fever around 5:45am. He was admitted on Monday.

Habibur Rahman, 21, of Faridpur, died at DMCH around 2:40pm. He was admitted on July 31.

In Dinajpur, a man named Rabiul Islam died at the M Abdur Rahim Medical College and Hospital around 5am on Tuesday, the hospital’s Director Dr Khairul Kabir told Dhaka Tribune.

The hospital is also treating at least 47 dengue patients at present, he said.

In Rangpur, a three-year-old girl named Rianna died of the fever at Rangpur Medical College Hospital early Tuesday.

Confirming the matter, RMCH spokesperson and Medicine Department Associate Professor Dr Asaduzzaman said that they were treating around 61 more dengue patients.


Additional reporting by Liakat Ali Badal, Rangpur, Faruk Hossain, Dinajpur, and Aminul Islam Babu, DMCH Correspondent

Top Brokers