This week I saw a film that requires viewer discretion. Let me confess upfront, it felt quite uncomfortable watching a film featuring graphic rape scenes, and that too sitting in an audience of sixty people aged 50 or above.
“Children of War” is the Bangla version of an Indian Hindi film. Only the words spoken in Hindi have been dubbed into Bangla, whenever Urdu is spoken Bangla subtitles are used. All the Hindi background songs have also been rerecorded in Bangla. The film does not represent the best of offbeat Hindi films, such as “Barfi” and “Gangs of Wasseypur,” but it bears their polish and as a result looks better than any of our films on the subject.
This film is an amalgamation of two sub genres: firstly, Mumbai’s Hindi Patriotic films where the Bangladesh Liberation War is considered a misnomer for the Indo-Pak War (an example is a film called “1971” which won the 2007 National Award for Best Hindi Film); secondly, Kolkata’s Bangla Parallel Cinema dealing with mature themes like adultery, rape, prostitution (an example is “Mondo Meyer Upakhyan” which won the 2003 National Award for Best Film). This film might also fit a third genre called “exploitation films,” that is, a low budget film trying to gain distinction by “exploiting” current trends.
I believe this is the third release this year about the liberation war, and it’s not even mid-year, moreover, this is the second release by a debutant director, the other being “71 er Sangram.”
It’s 1971 again. A Pakistani army officer imprisons sixteen women in a camp and systematically rapes them, part of their war strategy is to impregnate so many women that it becomes a nation of bastard children.
One of the women imprisoned is the wife of a journalist, for some reason his life is spared and he searches for her throughout the film. One particular woman is allowed to move freely in and out of the rape-camp, and she smuggles out weapons to freedom fighters. From time to time we flash forward to a young leader lecturing a crowd. The Bangla dubbing sounds a lot like a Unilever commercial set in rural Bengal, however, it’s refreshing to hear Pakistani officers speak proper Urdu, a major flaw in our films.
The best thing in the entire film are the scenes with two young actors, playing brother and sister (straight out of “Pather Panchali”) in a story that has no real connection to the narrative. Had the film told their story alone, we might have gotten something akin to “Ivan’s Childhood.” It’s important to bite as much as one can chew. Films are not all about the film-toys (camera, lens, music), it’s also about casting the right actors and nurturing them; the (screenplay) play is still the thing, even before the film can hope to become the thing.
I know of no other instance in film history where so many first time directors feel strongly about a single subject. Here are some examples of liberation war films made by first-time directors: “Meherjaan” (2011), “Joy Jatra” (2004), “Matir Moyna” (2002), “Aguner Parashmoni” (1995), “Nadir Naam Madhumati” (1994), “Ekatturer Jishu” (1993). The most talked about film on the subject by far is “Guerilla” (2011) which won 10 National Awards. Perhaps “Meherjaan” (2011) is the only film to be banned. The one closest to my heart, however, is the brilliant documentary “Muktir Gaan” (1995). Our films may lack craft, they may lack polish, they may lack the-movie-look, but they are made with sincerity.
It is difficult to recommend a film like “Children of War,” you will have to make up your mind yourself.
The fact that so many films are continuously being made on the subject proves there is a sense of dissatisfaction among filmmakers, maybe we feel: “The next one would be better.” One thing is clear though, the wait is not over yet. Perhaps Mostofa Sarwar Farooki should make the next one. Make no mistake, his kingdom might be small, but in his kingdom he is king.