Freedom fighter allowance gaffe: What are the reasons behind it?

Sultan Ahmed, son of late Syed Ali at Nehalpur village of Jhalokati Sadar upazila, enjoyed many benefits of the state, including the Freedom Fighters’ Allowance, for many years despite never taking part in the Liberation War. 

He did so by tampering with the freedom fighter (FF) certificate of Sultan Ahmed – the actual freedom fighter who resides in the same village and whose father’s name is also Syed Ali. The similarities in the names of the two men as well as that of their fathers’ names made the scam possible.

Nobody is allowed to be enlisted into the freedom fighters’ list without the recommendation of Jatio Muktijodha Council- Jamuka (National Freedom Fighter Council) as per rules; however, Sultan Ahmed was enlisted based only on his application in 2010.

The Ministry of Liberation War Affairs recently canceled Sultan Ahmed’s name from the freedom fighters’ list once the scam was proven by the concerned committee of Jamuka.

On December 9, the ministry published a list of 39,961 freedom fighters, whose names have been included in the gazette without the recommendation of Jamuka, on its website.

Jamuka had initially decided to verify the list through a separate committee in each district and sub-district across the country starting December 19, but later they decided to delay the verification process to January 9, 2021.

“If anyone is absent for any unavoidable reason on that day, they will likely get another day to meet. But hopefully, we can verify the listed heroic freedom fighters within January 2021,” said MD Zahurul Islam Rhohel.

“Though they might be real freedom fighters, they are going to be scrutinized as they were not recommended. Our goal is to establish an accurate list of heroic freedom fighters,” he told Dhaka Tribune.   

A total of 55,000 freedom fighters were enlisted between 2002 to 2014 without the recommendation of Jamuka, and in violation of the law. Of them, 44,000 freedom fighters were enlisted during the BNP-led government regime, and the rest during the ruling party’s regime. More than 15,000 of the freedom fighters have already been scrutinized by the government.

Liberation War Minister AKM Mozammel Huq recently told reporters that it has been decided to screen all those who have been gazetted without the recommendation of Jamuka since 2002 as the law makes recommendation mandatory.

Only freedom fighters listed through the civil gazette will be scrutinized in the process. Other categories of freedom fighters like the Indian list of freedom fighters, Shaheed civil gazette prepared by Kalyan Trust, Shaheed gazette listed by armed forces, etc will be out of the scope of verification.  

Did MIS find the gaffe?

According to the Ministry of Liberation War Affairs, some 238,387 freedom fighters have been gazetted since 1971, while 192,000 of them have applied for benefits. The ministry used to disburse a total of about Tk230 crore in monthly allowance to freedom fighters, with each of the 192,000 of them receiving Tk12,000 per month till August. 

However, the management information system (MIS) software that is used to handle the allowances only lists 171,000 beneficiaries since March. The large discrepancy raises many questions.

Complaints have surfaced that the local administration failed to detect the irregularities due to corruption and inefficiency.

Monthly benefits aside, each freedom fighter receives Tk20,000 for two Eid bonuses, Tk5,000 for victory day allowance and Tk2,000 for Bengali new year allowance, summing up to Tk1.71 lakh a year. If 20,000 people receive that amount through irregularities, then the financial loss of the state is some Tk342 crore.

Concerned officials have said the MIS system only accepts complete information on freedom fighters. Although between 500 and 1000 records are said to contain various errors according to an official seeking anonymity, even they cannot account for the massive discrepancy of 21,000. 

“It is too soon to say if 21,000 people were wrongful recipients of freedom fighter benefits, and the MIS data is still being looked into,” said Tapan Kanti Ghosh, secretary of the Ministry of Liberation War Affairs.

“More investigation is needed before frauds or irregularities can be ascertained,” he told Dhaka Tribune.

The government has been issuing Tk205 crore per month instead of Tk230 crore since September as the MIS system is reporting 21,000 fewer freedom fighters.

The government has also decided to transfer the money directly to the bank account of the beneficiary from January 2021. Currently, the recipients get their benefits manually from local administrations by producing their NID and other documents.