The third and last US presidential debate took place on Wednesday between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump. The debate broke no new ground except re-establish the acrimonious relationship between the two presidential candidates that has evolved in this election season, unprecedented in US history.
What was astounding, and in a way history-making, was Donald Trump’s unabashed assertion that he was not willing to accept the election results, no matter who wins.
He couched this bald faced announcement with words that once again established his devious character saying that he would give his final opinion on acceptance of the results later, meaning after the final results are known. This was classic Donald Trump talk, where he utters words that he can later paraphrase or change suiting the flavour of the time.
For the debates, Trump had been trained to be more presidential by abandoning his famous campaign bluster and insulting language. He had found it difficult to adjust to a more civil environment where form mattered and language had to be properly formulated.
He was asked to be logical, rational, polite, and responsive. Unfortunately, in the first two debates, his temperament got the better of him, and although he began in a civil tone, he succumbed later to his impulses, revealing his inability to hide his arrogance and irascible temper.
The third debate had raised a lot of interest among the voters, because it came in the back drop of a series of allegations by women of sexual misconduct against Trump, women who either came across him for work, or chanced to be with him for social or travel purposes.
In fact, the allegations were so serious that these prompted even Republican Party stalwarts to denounce Donald Trump; some even asking him to step away from the election.
Donald Trump had, of course, dismissed these allegations as nothing but conspiracies from the Democratic Party and derided his accusers as not worth his attention or time. But despite his denials, the opinion polls showed him falling behind his Democratic opponent, although his core supporters continued to rally behind him.
The last presidential debate, however, was not much focused on Trump’s sexual dalliances, but rather on major policy issues covering health care, taxation, national debt, immigration, entitlement programs (social security and Medicare), and foreign policy including fighting terrorism.
He managed to perform better in the third debate -- in the first half at least managing to appear sober, cool, somewhat rational, and seemed to have prepared himself on the topics. But then, he yielded again to his impulses on pressure from the moderator to stay focused on issues, and in particular in the face of criticism from Hillary Clinton on his dubious stand on a number of subjects.
Her critique of his policy stands on immigration, taxation, health care, and containment of terrorism elicited devious responses from him, and more often, diversion to attacks on Clinton with no relevance to the issues raised by the moderator.
He frequently interrupted his interlocutor in the debate with utterances that would either sarcastically refute her or call her names. At one stage, he even quipped: “Such a nasty woman,” a remark never made to a woman in a public place, least of all in a presidential debate. His conduct, toward the end demolished all the preparation his handlers had made before to make him appear more presidential.
Never in the history of presidential elections has a candidate so brazenly attacked the system and accused of rigging, that too weeks before election
Trump however, saved his most outrageous and incendiary statement for the last when he was asked by the moderator if he would accept the election results whatever they might be.
Initially, he dodged the question saying he would give his opinion after the elections. But when prodded by the moderator to say now if he would be willing to accept the results following democratic traditions, Trump had the audacity to respond that he would reserve his comment, adding that he would keep people in suspense. Suspense for what? That he would reveal his mind only after the elections?
Fortunately, for those who are impatient to hear what Trump had in mind, they did not have to wait till Election Day. The very next day, Trump declared before his cheery followers in a rally that he would accept the election results only if he won. There goes Trump’s version of democracy. The elections are fair if only I win. They are rigged if I don’t.
The surreal happening this year surrounding the presidential elections in the US and impossible rise of a maverick businessman like Donald Trump to seek the highest office of the country has all the trappings and smell of elections in a third world country beset by dictatorship and aspirants for public offices who want to get these by muscle power.
Trump has availed so far the opportunity to get the nomination by using a democratic system, but he is not willing to accept the system if the final result does not favour him. He is actually preparing himself and his followers for a defeat that he knows is inevitable by blaming a system that has proved to be one of the best in the world.
In the history of the US, the rigging of polls or accusation of rigging is fairly unknown. Only once in the recent past during the 2000 elections were there suggestions of wrong counting of votes in a county of Florida, which later the contestant Al Gore accepted and conceded victory to Bush. Never in the history of presidential elections has a candidate so brazenly attacked the system and accused of rigging, that too weeks before election.
A major reason why Donald Trump is trumpeting election-rigging and is making such incendiary comments by refusal to accept election results unless he wins, is the expectations he has raised among his core supporters about a dream of a Trump presidency.
His supporters, as well as a sizeable part of the Republican Party, are thoroughly opposed to a Hillary Clinton presidency and Democratic Party continuation in the Executive Office for the next four or eight years. Hence, they will accept any bluster or false depiction of reality from Donald Trump. Anything that advances the cause of the party is welcome to them, and that includes any lie or threat.
As the US goes into the elections on November 8, the possibilities are high that majority voters will swing for Hillary Clinton, raising the possibility of a Trump cry of foul play.
But as history has shown, such false cries have not swayed public opinion, and democracy has prevailed. Going forward, we can only hope that history will again prove right.
Ziauddin Choudhury has worked in the higher civil service of Bangladesh early in his career, and later for the World Bank in the USA.