The utter uniqueness of a President Trump

Since the 1876 general election in the United States, when a national commission headed by a Supreme Court justice had to render a decision on several disputed states, the contours of post-election consensus have been set in stone: The legitimacy of the results are not challenged in the streets but, if at all needed, litigated through the independent courts; opponents vanquished at the ballot box are not persecuted, jailed or prosecuted; and the media is not silenced.

This consensus is what largely distinguishes the exercise of electoral democracy in the US (and Western Europe) from the pale facsimiles found in, say, Congo, Bangladesh, or Uzbekistan. It is that consensus that Donald J Trump and his virulent followers threaten this year and that marks him out as the most unique major party candidate in a century and a half.

The peaceful transfer of power every four or eight years is a hallmark of American democracy, cherished as a cornerstone of maturity here and looked at with envy in those countries where pretend elections are used to legitimise unelected tyrants.

Every four years, just as the winner in the American presidential election magnanimously acknowledges the need to be a leader for every citizen, including those who voted for the other candidate, the loser graciously accepts the electoral verdict and congratulates the winner.

This has been the case even when there was serious suspicion of some irregularities (like in the 1960 election), because the stability of the democratic process is considered by both major parties to be more important that the parochial doubts of a nominee.

Donald Trump’s tirade about fraud and rigging, even before the actual elections day, is more than bluster: He has repeatedly alluded to street protests and armed insurrection in the event that the opinion polling is correct and he loses the race. Such invective is simply unprecedented in modern American history.

Not that there will be much magnanimity in Trump even if he were to win.

He has already called for, in a style far more common in Harare or Dhaka rather than in Washington or New York, the jailing of his opponent Hillary Rodham Clinton under a future Trump administration.

It should scare democracy activists around the world that a probable American president speaks in the troubling tones of tyrants who ‘win’ without real votes and then consider anything less than abject flattery to be defamatory and treasonous

Sure there will be all the niceties of due process before that, his minions, like former New York mayor Rudy Giuliani, had helpfully explained.

While such an outcome is unlikely, given the elaborate checks and balances built into the American system and the fierce independence of the professional bar and the bench, the chill sent by such Third World style vindictiveness is also a new low for national politics in the United States.

As a comparison, two American presidents were impeached during their terms of office; neither was criminally prosecuted, let alone  jailed, by his respective successors from the other party.

That kind of vendetta has simply not been part of the political dynamics in US since its first few decades.

The press is unlikely to be spared in the ideal Trump-ruled USA either. While it is fashionable for Republican candidates to routinely bash the mass media (except, of course, their darling Fox News which is, ironically, co-owned by a Hamas-loving Saudi prince), Donald Trump has taken that dislike to a venomous banana republic level.

His public rallies routinely feature calls for the jailing of unfriendly journalists, his tweets promise to punish those who insult him, and his campaign message is built around multiple conspiracy theories of newspapers and broadcast houses plotting against him.

Since the First Amendment to the United States constitution absolutely prohibits any criminal proceedings based on someone feeling “insulted” or “defamed” by speech or writing, Trump’s pronouncements suggest a cultural affinity for the kind of democracy where an editor can get sued 88 times in the space of a week for something he said on a talk show 10 years ago.

Again, with a judiciary which is very independent and looks askance at any effort to jeopardise the free press for spurious reasons like hurt feelings, it is unlikely that a Trump presidency will get to jail too many reporters.

Nevertheless, it should scare democracy activists around the world that a probable American president speaks in the troubling tones of tyrants who “win” without real votes and then consider anything less than abject flattery to be defamatory and treasonous.

Whether Mr Trump becomes president or not, the fact that a man of his temperament and tendencies came so close to it will affect America’s standing as the moral cheerleader for pluralism, democratisation, and free speech in the years to come.

Were he to become president, it is hard to see how American diplomats and NGOs will be able to keep a proverbial straight face and remind some budding dictator that criticism of a policy or questioning of a historical narrative does not equate to criminality and should not lead to jail sentences.

It is not that Donald Trump would have been a misfit of a president … in Zimbabwe, Singapore, or Uzbekistan, that is.

Esam Sohail is an educational research analyst and college lecturer of social sciences. He writes from Kansas, USA.