What are we failing to teach?

“He who studies rides in cars and carriages.” 

This familiar Bengali proverb is something many of us grew up hearing. It reflects a traditional understanding of education: Study hard, achieve good results, secure a good job, and build a prosperous life. 

There is nothing wrong with that aspiration. Education should certainly provide children with the knowledge and skills they need to earn a living and improve their financial and material well-being. 

But is that all education is meant to achieve?

Nearly 30 years ago, Unesco’s Delors Report (1996) identified four broad purposes of education: “Learning to know,” “learning to do,” “learning to be,” and “learning to live together.” 

The first two concern knowledge and skills, while the latter two focus on developing the whole person and preparing young people for life with others.

In our education system, academic knowledge and examination performance naturally receive considerable attention. Yet in practice, “learning to be” and “learning to live together” often receive far less attention than academic achievement and job-related skills. 

Are we educating students merely to pass examinations and acquire subject knowledge, or are we also helping them become confident, resilient, and emotionally healthy individuals who can understand others, navigate differences, build meaningful relationships and live well together?

Beyond the marks and grades

“Learning to be” is about becoming a complete human being, not simply a successful student. Education should help young people think independently, ask questions, communicate clearly, make thoughtful decisions, and reflect on their actions. 

It should also nurture emotional intelligence, so they can understand their emotions, recognize different perspectives, respond with empathy, and build healthy relationships. Along the way, they need to develop confidence, resilience, integrity, and a sense of responsibility. 

Yet these qualities can easily be overshadowed when educational success is measured mainly through marks, grades, examination results, and admission to prestigious institutions. Curiosity, creativity, empathy, and resilience may become secondary to the next examination or academic milestone.

Academic excellence matters. The concern arises when academic achievement becomes almost the sole measure of success. A student may achieve excellent grades and build a successful career while still struggling to handle failure, accept criticism and different opinions, acknowledge mistakes or work with people who are different. 

That takes us to a deeper purpose of education. Beyond what students know and what they achieve, what kind of human beings are they becoming?

The answer cannot come only from what is prescribed in the curriculum or written in textbooks. It also depends on how children experience and engage with the world around them, how they interact with others, respond to differences, handle disagreements, and take responsibility for their actions. That is where “learning to live together” becomes equally important.

A child walks into a classroom carrying much more than a schoolbag. He or she carries a family background, social, and religious identity, hopes, fears, abilities, opportunities, and disadvantages. Yet once inside the classroom, all children are expected to learn together. The deeper question is whether we are also helping them learn how to live together.

This matters deeply in a socially diverse and economically unequal society such as Bangladesh. Children grow up with different levels of wealth, different beliefs, abilities, languages, family circumstances, and social experiences. 

From an early age, they begin to notice who is respected, who is ignored, who is included, and who is left out. In this way, they begin to form ideas about fairness, often without being explicitly taught.

Discrimination does not always appear as open exclusion. It can take the form of a joke, a stereotype, a label, an unequal expectation or an assumption about what a child can achieve. 

A child from a poorer family may be made to feel inferior. A child with a disability may be viewed as incapable rather than supported to participate. A child who is different from the majority may gradually feel that belonging is something to be earned rather than something everyone deserves.

Schools can either reinforce these attitudes or challenge them. A school that teaches equality but allows a child to be humiliated because of family circumstances sends a contradictory message. A school that speaks about inclusion but does not enable a child with a disability to participate fully does the same. Similarly, when academic competition dominates school life, children may learn to see one another more as rivals than as people with whom they can learn and grow.

This is why values cannot be taught only through lessons, definitions, or moral instruction. Children learn from what they experience. 

A child who is listened to learns that his or her voice matters. A child who is treated with dignity learns what dignity means. A child who is allowed to make a mistake without humiliation learns that failure is part of learning. A child who sees others treated fairly begins to understand fairness not as an abstract principle, but as something that should guide everyday life.

The same is true of disagreement. Children will argue, compete, form friendships, and sometimes hurt one another. School can teach them that disagreement does not have to lead to hostility. Learning to live together does not mean teaching children to agree on everything. It means helping them learn how to disagree without hatred, humiliation, or exclusion.

Cooperation also has to be experienced, not simply encouraged. When children work together on projects, solve problems collectively, or take responsibility for shared activities, they learn to listen to different opinions, share responsibilities, and recognize the contribution of others. These are not activities outside education. They are part of what education should accomplish.

The purpose is not to make children identical in their beliefs, abilities or experiences. It is to help them understand that difference does not have to become division. In a diverse society, children need to learn how to live with people who may think differently, believe differently, or come from circumstances very different from their own.

Learning to live with nature

“Learning to live together” should extend beyond human relationships to our relationship with nature. Children need to experience that they are not separate from the natural world, but part of it, and that nature is not merely a resource for human use. It has its own value and deserves care and respect.

This understanding cannot come from textbooks alone. Children need opportunities to experience nature, observe living things, grow plants, understand water and waste, and see how human actions affect the world around them.

The aim is not simply to teach children about the environment, but to help them develop a sense of belonging to nature and responsibility towards it. To live well is not only to live well with one another, but to live with nature in a way that respects its right to exist and flourish.

Education for life

Education should prepare children not only for work, but for life; not only to compete, but to cooperate; and not only to succeed as individuals, but to live together as human beings. 

Its real measure lies not only in what children know or achieve, but in who they become and how they treat others. Can they live meaningful lives, respect differences, respond to inequality, participate responsibly in society, and care for the world they share?

The question before us, therefore, is not simply what technical skills our children acquire, but what kind of people our education institutions are helping them become.

And ultimately, what kind of society will those people build?

Dr Somnath Saha is Assistant Professor, Brac IED, Brac University.