How leaders should think during a pandemic

Homo sapiens are currently experiencing a testing time, irrespective of colour, race, religion, and country. Leaders are still struggling to understand and determine which way the Covid-19 pandemic will steer the world.

However, it seems some leaders/ countries are still not convinced -- or are reluctant to act, despite a large body of knowledge and historical evidence on global pandemics in past centuries. It is because, unfortunately, we live in a society where parochial and vested interests often get priority over knowledge, truths, and humanity!

In most of the decision-making processes these days, there is a tendency for many top leaders to jump into less exhaustive, shortsighted, politically-motivated quick fixes and reactive fire-fighting strategies. It is difficult for them to accept the realities that are at odds with their typical mindset (a mental pre-disposition influenced by own beliefs) and also the comfort zones, which they have taken for granted.

Eventually, it is always the ordinary citizens who pay a high price at the receiving end of such decisions. Each bad decision takes us one more step backward from mankind’s progress towards a civilized and just society.

The Covid-19 saga is certainly different than governments’ response to other big global events, for example, the Iraq war, or climate change, as the lives of the nation’s own people are in jeopardy, a position which is hard to defend under such a dire situation. As a result, many governments have been compelled to adopt totally people-centric decisions, shifting away from their usual policy-centric comfort zones.

Leaders who fail to move quickly from their more familiar milieus are already facing criticism and backlashes from citizens and other corners of the globe. For example, people in Brazil demonstrated against President Jair Bolsonaro for his inability to tackle the outbreak, undermining efforts to protect lives by preventing the spread of the virus.

After many years of seemingly governing in a vacuum, many governments are promoting extraordinary measures and initiatives to help their citizens weather the financial and health consequences of the global pandemic.

The response brings to mind Abraham Lincoln’s famous saying: “Government is by the people, of the people, and for the people.” Some media have already reported that after many years of disquiet, people have started to feel the importance and role of government in their daily lives. Top leaders are now paying heed to expert advice, scientific research and modelling, and taking measures based on those suggestions, even if contrary to their own values and policies.

However, unlike any other project or crisis management, “pandemic planning” and management is a very different ball game with long-term consequences. It is about making sure human life and existence remain viable and operational while maintaining the social norms, values, and the rule of law during and after the pandemic.

As such, pandemic planning warrants a thorough analysis of multi-dimensional factors backed by research and evidence-based wisdom with cross-disciplinary perspectives and inputs. In dealing with Covid-19, many countries wasted time to mobilize and exploit the full potential of their existing resources. It is often the case that our “post-event lessons learned” from previous cases remain within books and journal articles and are hardly being used or consulted at the time of real crisis.

Amongst those, for example, whole-of-society approaches suggested by the collaborative governance literature, calls for cooperation, trust-building, resource sharing, and collaborative decision making among multiple levels of government, business, non-profits, and the public in general.

Decision science frameworks offer a wide range of choices to evaluate alternative policy options under complex and changing conditions. While mathematical and statistical models by epidemiologists are important tools for pandemic planning and response, they should also be complemented by contemporary management knowledge.

This domain of knowledge provides transformative skillsets through agile project management, change management, and a lean methodology to ensure effective stakeholder engagement, communication channels, and a timely and judicious use of resources are maintained.

Similarly, the input from social scientists and psychologists about the behavioural and sociocultural factors, and fundamental regulatory and ethical debates from lawyers are also important for effective mitigation strategies.

A thorough pandemic planning with clear visions and missions should include clear strategies in each stage, multi-dimensional modelling to improve the effectiveness of the response, synthesization of available data to provide enhanced situational awareness, options, and risk analysis to predict the future courses and mitigation strategies with likely social and economic costs and impact in the short and long terms.

A robust yet agile pandemic plan can reduce the delivery cost as well as the loss of lives, even in an extremely volatile situation. The pandemic planning should be followed by pandemic management. This entails complex coordination mechanisms of many different departments of the health and social care systems, emergency services, multiple levels of national and local government, civil society, communications and media, cultural and religious organizations.

It’s not just hand sanitizers

In the heat of the moment, as it is happening now, everyone’s focus is on essential paraphernalia and instrumentsand resources, such as ventilators, masks, sanitizers etc. However, accumulating the essential instruments and resources is not a solution unless proper coordination and communication mechanisms are developed so that the right instruments can be effectively operationalized at the right moment at the right place.

Often it is seen that essential equipment and instruments are lying unutilized or underutilized because other peripheral/associated issues, including doctors, operators, and management issues, are not set to function in harmony under a clear and robust management framework.

This results in time delays and the potential loss of lives. Simple mismanagement and coordination lapses amongst different bodies and in the end to end value-chain can jeopardize the whole effort and planning, leading to chaos and confusion.

We have already experienced an element of this, even in a developed country like Australia, where mixed and contradictory messages from federal and state governments about school closures and measures for dealing with Ruby Princess cruise ship passengers created considerable confusion, dilemma, followed by some penalties.

Ironically, many developing countries with varied socio-economic and cultural backgrounds are yet to fathom the importance of such welldefined and structured governance and management coordination framework, which is extremely critical for managing pandemics.

In the closely-knit globalized society of the 21st century, Covid-19 has taught another lesson that mere local management is just not good enough unless effective global coordination and management is in place where people’s movements are far more frequent and complex than in the past.

A significant gap also exists nationally and globally in integrating the strategies and policies amongst nations. Pandemics are a global issue, so local strategies, disharmony, and an inability to reach a global consensus and strong participation in control could result in some unintended consequences and loss of lives. Italy could be an unfortunate example of being caught unaware and thus missing the boat of international coordination and learning.

In such circumstances, the United Nations could possibly play a more active role and exert far greater control in enforcing robust, concerted, and united strategies. However, this is not happening due to the current status quo of the UN with fragmentation and polarization of the world order, which is again hindered by the vested interest and mindset of our top leaders.

This is probably high time countries should make a serious effort leaving behind its past baggage, with a strong will to regain the lost status quo and power of the UN to avoid further mismanagement of crisis like Covid-19. The UN should have a strong mandate to manage global crisis impartially without any prejudice, influence, and interference, and just for humanity. On a final note, every member of the human race has the responsibility to tackle the Covid-19 virus. We can all contribute, starting from managing health safety at a personal level and family/community level.

Most importantly those with essential skillset should, if possible, exert their expertise or influence at the various national and international decision-making processes and pandemic planning and management.

In these final hours, when I am writing this piece, the tide is already hitting our shores and we must keep our heads cool and follow the pandemic plan diligently. While dealing with the big picture, we should not lose sight of taking care of critical members in society.

This includes doctors and nurses because if they all become sick, the rest will be in a severe state of risk, and there will be no brains and hands to tackle the crisis.

Ahmed Imran is an Information Systems academic at University of Canberra. He teaches and researches project management, e-Governance, and socio-cultural impact and transformation due to ICT.