The first nursery of hate

Whether an independent and credible investigation will ever uncover the full backstory behind the massacre at Holey Artisan Bakery, I do not know. What I do know is that the shock reverberating through the country, and indeed the world, that affluent, well-educated kids were perpetrators, shouldn’t exactly be a shock if we are being honest. A cursory review of the leadership of the various branches of the global Islamist terror movement yields a compelling list of engineers, physicians, and academics with educational, professional, and family backgrounds that should have, conventionally, placed them somewhere far away from desert caves and mountain dugouts. The 9/11 hijackers were, for example, scions of wealthy families who had all the worldly goods they needed, putting into grave doubt the lazy theory that terrorism is explained by a set of buzzwords like “poverty,” “disenfranchisement,” “marginalisation” that are favoured by the progressive professoriate in the West. Sorry, but the seeds of radicalisation are often planted right in the living rooms and dining tables of middle class, upper middle class, and, yes, upper class families from Kuala Lampur to Dhaka to Karachi to Jeddah. Ask yourself: Have you known too many discussions in Bangladesh -- from your living room to the office canteen -- that touch on global affairs without, ultimately, finding some nefarious connection of the holy trinity of Jews, America, and “the West” to every mishap in the world? Sure, these insinuations and verbal treatises are far more polite and polished than you’d hear from the self-declared jihadis in the Tora Bora mountains, but is the message that much different? You don’t have to take my word for it. Just do a random perusal through that beautiful window to our individual mindsets called Facebook … and see how many of your friends and family are busily spinning deep and dark tales about how some currency exchange rate is the handiwork of the Americans, funded by the Zionists, and done in the service of those “immoral” Westerners. I see this kind of nonsense not from uneducated fools, but very well-educated people in Bangladesh every day on social media. To this day, for example, I have not forgotten the chill that went down my spine a year ago when I saw an Australian educated business professor of a reputable private university in Dhaka nonchalantly pen his thoughts on Facebook about how “Hitler left the job undone” regarding Jews. Mind you, this is not some madrasa teacher with a cap and beard; this is a self-proclaimed progressive with all the right academic credentials and a wannabe James Bond persona. He is hardly an exception. What makes Bangladeshis even more susceptible to such irresponsible messages is the toxic combination of continuously imbibing a robust dose of cultural and religious chauvinism coupled with very little material progress to show for it. Fed from their very childhood that their culture, language, and religion is absolutely the most awesome in the history of mankind, the teenager and young adult gets a little jolt of reality coming of age and realising that this fond trifecta of the perfect culture, language, and religion has failed to provide a fraction of the quality of life that he regularly witnesses in the West, thanks to social media, television, and movies. I mean, you are already convinced that your birthright heritage of culture, language, and religion is simply an unparalleled asset compared to all other people in the world, and then you run into the reality that that asset has not yielded much beyond a city where traffic doesn’t move, the connected are always above the law, and the quality of life for the average person is utterly mediocre compared to what their peers of the “wrong” language, religion, and culture in London or Singapore or Perth enjoy. When such cognitive dissonance strikes, what more soothing solution to the conundrum than some cocktail of conspiracy theories where some nefarious “other” has robbed you of the progress that should have been yours by the right of being so superior intrinsically to your peers everywhere else. And bingo, you are now quite susceptible to those in the shadows -- physical or cyber -- who want to prey on those insecurities and inadequacies to further their own murderous agenda. Fortunately, not all such insecure youth fall prey; unfortunately, it only takes a few to cause utter carnage as we saw in Gulshan a few days ago. The hands that struck the blow belonged to youthful murderers, the machetes and guns in those hands came from distant hate-peddlers, but the hate in the hearts of those young men was nourished for the first time in the living rooms, canteens, and social media pages where they came of age.