A symbol of political determination

What separates the haves from the have-nots in the world? Why are some nations rich and others poor? In fact, what has allowed some nations to jump-start growth to only fall into recession after a brief positive run? And why could only a few countries maintain economic progress over the long-run?

If Bangladesh truly aspires to experience transformative economic change over the next few decades, it must explore lessons from countries that have attained remarkable economic transformation in one single lifetime. That is, what has allowed South Korea -- a country that had a per capita income of less than $100 in 1955 -- to attain such economic height in one generation?

Why did countries like North Korea, Zimbabwe, and Congo fail to replicate such a growth miracle? How was China -- a country infested with famine and economic under-performance in its initial journey -- able to economically turn around so decisively after 1978?

Can Bangladesh replicate some of these positive economic experiences? What should Bangladesh aspire to do if we aim for such decisive economic turnaround? While a comprehensive understanding of the noted questions is still missing, there are a few clues that hold valuable policy lessons.

One fundamental feature that starkly varies across rich and poor nations is the former's capacity to develop effective institutions, productive infrastructure, and high-quality human capital. In other words, one of the key drivers of modern economic growth is to create effective institutions that can be used to deliver productive infrastructure and highly useful skills within its labour force. That is why it is prudent to say that Bangladesh’s development journey has turned a corner with the completion of Padma Bridge. 

Why is the completion of Padma Bridge so significant?

A few critical reasons

First, after the infamous backing out of the World Bank on weak and largely unsubstantiated accusations, state institutions faced a major dilemma concerning whether to proceed with this mega infrastructural commitment. Since Bangladesh not only had, prior to 2009, no track record of completing a project of such scale without any external assistance from development partners, the "know-how" required to conceive, design, financially manage, and execute such an endeavor was almost missing from the state apparatus.

Thus, the political determination to commit to this project by Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina not only helped Bangladesh achieve a remarkable feat, but the experience has created useful “know-how” concerning how to financially and physically manage these projects, which has enhanced the capacities of our state institutions. Thus, it is not surpassing that a country which celebrated a mere 1.12km long flyover in Mohakhali in 2004, costing approximately Tk114 crore, has now overseen the construction of so many critical infrastructural and power projects within a matter of one decade -- amounting to investments of over $25 billion in total. 

Of course, while this is a very notable milestone, there is little doubt that further improvements are needed in how we select mega infrastructure projects, how we estimate their social and economic return, how we decide to finance them, and how efficiently we decide to execute them -- so that cost and time overruns do not undermine the economic returns of such ventures.

It is also necessary that the selection criteria of such projects prioritize ventures which  promote private investments, especially in the export sector, so that these investments generate much needed foreign reserves that can be used for servicing the foreign debt incurred for its construction. 

Second, if we evaluate the direct and indirect benefits of the Padma Bridge, the construction of Padma Bridge will provide road and rail links between the relatively less-developed Southwest region of the country and the more-developed eastern half that includes the capital of Dhaka and the port city of Chittagong. 

By facilitating transportation across the river, the bridge is expected to lead to a greater integration of regional markets within the Bangladeshi national economy. It is also expected that the Padma Bridge will have the most significant economic and poverty impacts in Khulna and Barisal Divisions -- the Southwest region of Bangladesh. In other words, the Padma Bridge is likely to play an instrumental role in reducing regional disparity -- and fueling more productive economic activities in the Southwest region of Bangladesh. 

This also leads to one question: If the Padma Bridge carries such huge scopes for Bangladesh’s economy, especially for the geographically detached Southwest region, were the governance concerns reasonable enough for the abandonment of such a crucial project?

Can the World Bank’s decision have any credible economic logic? Did the World Bank provide any evidence that the $1.2bn that they committed to Padma Bridge was better used anywhere else?

The World Bank was originally conceived to create supporting conditions for economically backward countries, so that they can help nation states mobilize much needed resources for projects which they cannot support on their own. Thus, when the World Bank backs out from a project on charges of corruption, it not only hurts a country economically, but it also undermines the credibility of a nation at the international arena. Fortunately, for Bangladesh, it was able to dodge this painful bullet through some careful maneuvering at the international arena. 

In fact, if we revisit all the unfavourable narratives which complicated the execution of this transformative infrastructural investment, it provides an insightful political economy case study concerning how difficult it is to do something productive in a developing country. Perhaps a thorough political economy analysis of this project will help us understand why developing economies find it so difficult to economically catch up with developed nations, and how even productive investments often do not receive the support of key development partners for potentially political reasons.

A new point

This episode in Bangladesh’s development history also marks an important point: Developing countries must start appreciating leadership that commits to long-run transformative projects, which is not only a means to mobilize critical investments needed for enhancing the productivity of the private sector by reducing transportation and transaction costs, but by also reducing the authoritative power of development agencies who often play a dubious role in the international development sector -- by aligning their activities closely with the political objectives of a few Western powers. 

Ultimately, the political determination of developing countries, in solving their own problems with limited support from external actors, can help countries find the confidence in their own capacities to change their fortune. This was witnessed in Meiji, Japan after 1868 and present-day China after 1978.

Bangladesh, too, can replicate such transformative economic experience -- and the completion of Padma Bridge shows that political determination used for productive endeavors can surely catalyze both economic and political modernization in Bangladesh, and help create the foundation for a second economic leap that we must start preparing for in the coming days. 

 

Dr Ashikur Rahman is a Senior Economist at the Policy Research Institute of Bangladesh (PRI). He can be reached at ashrahman83@gmail.com.