THG (LON: THG) or earlier The Hut Group shares are down 9% this morning. THG shares don’t seem to have any specific news to drive this, a change in market opinion perhaps. There’s been no formal announcement of market sensitive news for a couple of weeks now either.
THG is an interesting example of the problem with a company run by a hard driving entrepreneur. Of course, to go from a standing start to creating a £1 billion business requires both drive and an insistence that I’m right. No one ever has turned some note on a piece of paper into a £billion without having confidence in their own opinion. That does then pose problems when that business is more mature. When there are outside shareholders for example. Or even a bid for the company: “THG (LON: THG) - formerly The Hut Group - shares dropped 13% in London today as the company announced that it had rejected the very idea of an approach from Apollo. We're all sure that shareholders are very grateful to Matt Moulding for protecting their interests this well. At which point the consistent critique from some in The City, that Moulding just isn't the right person to be running a publicly listed company, might have a point. For this isn't the sort of thing that someone in that position is quite supposed to do. Now, that Apollo - as many others have done recently - was trying to bottom feed is obvious enough. The THG share price is well below where it started. Something that, given losses might be reasonable. But there's also a definite feeling that THG is trading below a reasonable valuation of the business. There must, therefore, be something holding that valuation back.” Moulding may well have been right there.
THG share price from Google Finance
We also looked at THG here. The latest piece of interest was a little while back: “THG, the London-listed online health and beauty retailer, is in advanced talks to buy City AM, the London-based business newspaper which is teetering on the brink of administration. Sky News has learnt that THG, which owns brands such as Cult Beauty and Look Fantastic, is negotiating the purchase of City AM with BDO, the accountancy firm which is on standby to handle its insolvency.” And THG did buy it too. Which is fine.
Except that it’s another example of how difficult it is to restrain the hard charging entrepreneur. Matt Moulding has been complaining bitterly about short sellers. Going so far as to at least imply that there was nefarity. City AM is, as the name implies, a newspaper for and about The City, the financial markets. We predict, with absolute 100% confidence, that City AM will now run articles insisting on how terrible short selling is. Which does sound more like a vanity project for the CEO than a useful addition to the business of selling protein shakes online.
As we say, the very things that get a business off the ground in the first place can become problems later on.