‘DNA test not enough to identify dead workers’

Only DNA samplings are not enough to identify the dead workers of industrial tragedies like Rana Plaza or Tazreen Factory fire since most of the bodies are handed over to relatives without collecting DNA samples, speakers said at a discussion yesterday.

The roundtable titled “No Grave to Grieve: The Search for Missing Garment Workers and the Challenges of DNA Technology in Bangladesh” was organised by Activist Anthropologist, a group working with the lists of missing garments workers since the 2005 Spectrum Garments tragedy.

Prof Sharif Akhtaruzzaman of the National Forensic DNA Profiling Laboratory of Dhaka Medical College said there were many chances that the bodies had been handed over to wrong families since the process was done based on visual identification marks.

“The DNA lab can identify all the bodies only if it can collect samples from all the victims,” he said adding that the DNA profiles of 105 bodies from the Rana Plaza collapse incident still remained unidentified. To solve these types of problems, he suggested setting up of a makeshift morgues at the disaster sites to collect DNA samples.

Earlier, Saydia Gulrukh, one of the organisers, read out the keynote paper. Based on field investigation she claimed that in some cases, remains of two workers or more were put in one bag which also led to misidentification by the DNA lab.

Teachers, activists and labour organisers were present at the discussion that took place at the Daily Star Centre. Syed Sultan Uddin Ahmed, assistant executive director of Bangladesh Institute of Labour Studies (BILS); Roy Ramesh Chandra, general secretary of IndustriALL Bangladesh Council; and Prof Tanzimuddin Khan from Dhaka University also spoke among others.

Jahangirnagar University teacher Prof Anu Mohammad said it should be made mandatory for every factory and the BGMEA to preserve the list of workers.“If it is available, then there will be no need to examine all the DNA profiles and every family will at least able to get the body.”

He also expressed frustration as the government was yet to formulate a compensation policy. “This is unexpected after continuous disasters in the garments sector.”

Human rights activist Hameeda Hossain said while conducting DNA tests, local administration and representatives could investigate to identify the deceased workers’ families.

Moshrefa Mishu, president of Garment Sramik Oikya Parishad, said: “If there are active trade unions, then they can provide the list of total workers.”