‘No MSG added’ - The racist history of ‘Chinese restaurant syndrome’

Monosodium glutamate (MSG) has long been the subject of unwarranted controversy. For years the rumours about “Chinese restaurant syndrome” filtered through from the USA to the rest of the world without any scientific basis. 

Initially, MSG was created by fermenting seaweed broth into a synthetic chemical compound, and it proved to be a highly effective flavour enhancer. 

Consequently, it gained widespread popularity as an additive, particularly in Chinese restaurants and many Asian recipes. 

However, the negative reputation surrounding MSG is closely tied to the time of its discovery, which coincided with the enforcement of the 1882 Chinese Exclusion Act by the US government, contributing to unwarranted suspicions and concerns about this seasoning.

How did the rumours begin? 

As xenophobia in the United States intensified towards Asians, false accusations about MSG being unpleasant and causing symptoms and illness also increased, suggesting that the fact that it was manufactured by an Asian corporation or Asian person had contributed to the villainization of a flavouring ingredient.

According to author Jessica Byrne’s claims, the first baseless claim against MSG was a "Chinese Restaurant syndrome" letter published in the New England Journal of Medicine in 1968 that blamed MSG for various symptoms.  

The letter was uncovered to be a hoax, but the myth remains. The US Food and Drug Administration has long approved MSG for consumption, and studies have failed to show that the chemical causes the alleged "syndrome".

Despite the fact that many American companies use MSG, the author immediately demonstrated that this letter was created solely to insult Asians by emphasising that the symptoms from MSG were "chinese" or an "Asian mistake." 

The media and the general public were ready to join on the anti-MSG bandwagon once the letter went viral, further fanning the flames of xenophobia. That's why you'll find "Chinese restaurant syndrome" defined in Merriam-Webster. 

Research into the effects of MSG on human physiology had begun thereafter, however these studies have used implausibly high doses—roughly five to thirty times higher than what is typically used in Asian cooking—proving that they are motivated by racism. 

Instead of adding MSG to food in typical amounts and letting it promote digestion on its own, researchers injected large doses directly into the stomachs of the rats. 

Then, they concluded that MSG caused excitotoxicity and cognitive deficiency, adding to the widespread belief that the food additive is harmful.

Based on these findings, many Chinese restaurants and commercial food products then boasted "no added MSG" labels to reassure customers that their food is risk-free to eat. 

The Truth 

Only recently has MSG been deemed safe for daily use, including by youngsters and pregnant women, according to updated and accurate research. 

However, the improved reputation of MSG was not promoted as heavily as the negative one, so widespread mistrust persists.   

According to the BBC, in 2020, Ajinomoto, the company that manufactured MSG, launched a campaign to rehabilitate its image by suing Merriam-Webster over its definition of "chinese restaurant syndrome," which it claims occurs in "susceptible persons" after they consume "food and especially Chinese food heavily seasoned with monosodium glutamate." 

Glutamate (MSG) is an amino acid that is naturally present in almost every food, as stated by author Theresa Hedrick: "the more free glutamate there is, the more Glutamate there will be." This includes protein-rich foods like eggs, meat, cheese, tomatoes, grape juice, mushrooms, walnuts, broccoli, and so on. 

For decades, a perfectly acceptable and harmless flavouring agent that occurs naturally in a wide variety of fruits, vegetables, and proteins was unfairly maligned as poisonous and nearly inedible for the sake of spreading false and allegations towards Asians.