Speakers: Bangladesh needs comprehensive approach to tackle Myanmar crisis

Bangladesh should set a proper strategy to analyze the full picture and deal with various issues of Myanmar, instead of focusing only on the Rohingya crisis, speakers at a roundtable discussion have said.

“We need to form a task force under the Prime Minister's Office that has all the representation of key ministries to involve them in the response mechanism,” they added.

The speakers were deliberating at a roundtable, titled “Instability In Myanmar: Implications for Bangladesh and the region”, organized by the leading English daily Dhaka Tribune and Bangladesh Institute of Peace and Security Studies (BIPSS) at a Dhaka hotel as part of a series of discussions on important national and international issues.

In the opinion of the speakers, Bangladesh has ignored Myanmar historically and politically. However, there has been big influence exerted by the big players, including India, China, the US and Russia, along with some Asian countries such as Singapore, South Korea and Thailand.

ANM Muniruzzaman, BIPSS President Mehedi Hasan/Dhaka Tribune

BIPSS President Maj Gen (Retd) ANM Muniruzzaman moderated the roundtable while Dhaka Tribune Editor Zafar Sobhan delivered the final remarks. The roundtable brought together academics, local and foreign security experts, diplomats, former and serving law enforcement agency officials, journalists, and university students.

Speakers said Bangladesh has to focus on the Rohingya issue in the geo-political context as the wave of Rohingya refugees heading towards Bangladesh due to internal conflict and insurgency in Myanmar is on the rise again.

Major General (retd) Md Shahidul Haque Mehedi Hasan/Dhaka Tribune

Major General Md Shahidul Haque (retd), former defence attache at the Bangladesh embassy in Myanmar and former ambassador to Libya, Umme Salma Tarin, Assistant Professor at the Department of International Relations at Bangladesh University of Professionals, and Parvez Karim Abbasi, Assistant Professor, Department of Economics, East West University, spoke on the occasion as panelists.

Md Shahidul Haque presented a bilateral and regional aspect of instability in Myanmar, focusing on the coup, military rule, and its consequence for Bangladesh and the region.

He described Myanmar as a very complex country due to its different manner of operating compared with other states. Regarding instability in Myanmar, he argued, implications of the instability do not affect only Bangladesh but the entire region.

He said: “Myanmar has some insurgency groups—they can do business, they have a power plant, casino, they do the drug business. They have weapons and weapon-making factories.”

“There are currently 12-15 various insurgent groups fighting in Myanmar's states, all the inner instability and infighting has influence beyond the border of Myanmar, particularly Bangladesh border.


Umme Salma Tarin Mehedi Hasan/Dhaka Tribune


Assistant Professor Tarin deliberated on the role of the National Unity Government (NUG) of Myanmar, which is the primary opposition to the military junta that took over in 2021.

The National League for Democracy (NLD) was deposed along with State Counsellor of Myanmar Aung San Suu Kyi by the Tatmadaw—Myanmar's military. The Tatmadaw is still exercising overall control of the territory.

She also discussed the current crisis in Myanmar in the regional context.

She said: “We shouldn't think about only bilateral Bangladesh-Myanmar issues; we can think in terms of considering geo-political and geo-economic points of view.”

“The international community is very calculative regarding Myanmar and its issues, as Myanmar is a big factor in Southeast Asia. Bangladesh is not the only country being affected by the crisis in Myanmar, as it has also violated airspace in Thailand and people have been killed in Thailand also,” she added.

India has also been facing trouble due to the instability in Myanmar, as some 60,000 people migrated to India from Myanmar. However, India has now successfully sealed its border, but a conflict between the two countries remains.

She said: “Accessing Myanmar's ports is important for China due to the presence of its navy in the Indian Ocean, as China wants significant control over the region.”

Parvez Karim Abbasi Mehedi Hasan/Dhaka Tribune

Parvez Karim Abbasi discussed the economic aspects of Myanmar as it is facing several sanctions.

He said Myanmar is facing severe economic stress and various indicators are indicating a downward trend. For example, Myanmar's GDP is down to $1,400, the poverty rate has risen to 40%, vaccination is the lowest among Asian countries and inflation was 18% last year.

However, Myanmar's economy will not immediately collapse as it retains cash flow due to various trade deals with China, Singapore, Japan, South Korea, India, Russia and Pakistan despite the sanctions.  

Parvez Karim Abbasi said: “Myanmar follows military fiscalism as the Tatmadaw has a presence in economic activities and they have control over businesses like banking, insurance, tourism, oil and the gas sector.

“Trading narcotics is another means for Myanmar to survive economically, as it has a $40b market.”  

“Myanmar is second the largest producer of heroin, and the biggest producer of yaba. Shan state has the biggest yaba-producing factory in the world,” he added.

“Yaba and crystal meth are coming from Myanmar to Bangladesh, which is a matter of national security and one of the biggest threats to our youths,” he added.

Maj Gen (Retd) ANM Muniruzzaman said: “We have analyzed that the PDF (People's Defence Force, an armed wing of the NUG) is exacting revenge on several insurgent groups. However, in some cases, the PDF and insurgent groups have jointly fought against the Tatmadaw. Meanwhile, the PDF has factions –there is hardly PDF unity across Myanmar..

He said: “We have to have a very clear understanding of the state of Myanmar. There are many countries which have various interests regarding Myanmar, like China, the US, India and now Russian interest.”

He added: “a single strategy with Myanmar cannot be effective, it needs a combined and comprehensive approach.”

 

Zafar Sobhan, Editor of Dhaka TribuneMehedi Hasan/Dhaka TribuneDhaka Tribune Editor Zafar Sobhan said: “Myanmar is geo-politically and geo-economically important. We should understand the full picture rather than only focus on the Rohingya issue.

We have to focus on the Rohingya issue in a geo-political context as there are so many influential actors, especially India, China, and Russia along with some Asian countries such as Singapore, South Korea, and Thailand, he added.

Lt Abu Rushd, Editor of Bangladesh Defence JournalMehedi Hasan/Dhaka Tribune

Lt Abu Rushd, editor of Bangladesh Defence Journal, asked the panelists: “Why has Myanmar been procuring ballistic missiles from Russia, and submarines from China. Is it for insurgents or increasing military power?”

Ms Ayesha Kabir, Consulting Editor of Prothom Alo Mehedi Hasan/Dhaka Tribune

Consultant Editor of Prothom Alo Ayesha Kabir  asked if Bangladesh could expect India to immediately put pressure on Myanmar regarding Rohingya repatriation, as India is a very good friend.

Md Touhid Hossain, Former Foreign Secretary Mehedi Hasan/Dhaka Tribune

Md Touhid Hossain, former foreign secretary, said Myanmar has no intention of taking back the Rohingya. A such, the issue has never been resolved permanently. 

“China or India wouldn't help. We need a new strategy, and new friends to solve it,” he added.

Ambassador Shahed Akhtar, Former Ambassador & Secretary Chairman, Asia House Mehedi Hasan/Dhaka Tribune

Former ambassador Shahed Akhtar, Dr Mohammad Zahidul Islam Khan, dean of the Faculty of Science, Social Science & Liberal Arts at BSMRAAU, and East-West University student Md Mosaddek also spoke at the session.