Law proposing multiple power, gas tariff hikes decried

Already grappling to tackle the growing expenditure at the power and energy sector, the government has resorted to increase power and gas tariffs more than once a year.

However, experts have criticised the move, claiming that repeated hike of power and gas prices every year will weigh heavily on the masses, especially the low and middle income groups. 

The decision will also pave the way to uncontrolled spending in the sector and encourage irregularities, they feared. 

But the Ministry of Power, Energy and Mineral Resources disagrees, saying repeated price hike of power and gas was mandatory to keep the momentum in the sector going.

The arguments have come at a time when the Bangladesh Energy Regulatory Commission (BERC) is all set to announce the next power price hike, for both retail and bulk consumers, following a four-day hearing held between November 28 and December 3.

Gas prices were raised on July 1, at a weighted average of around 32% per cubic foot.

The government increased power tariff at least four times at the retail level and twice for bulk users in the last 10 years. In 2017, the BERC had hiked the prices twice through a single order, but later retreated.

On the other hand, gas prices were raised five times since 2009.

Cabinet on December 30 in principle cleared the draft of the BERC (amendment) Act 2019, with the provision of changing the tariff of gas and power more than once every fiscal year — which the existing BERC Act 2003 does not allow.

Prof Dr M Shamsul Alam, energy adviser of Consumers' Association of Bangladesh (CAB), alleged that the rising expenditure in the power sector was not under the government’s control.

“The government kept failing to stop that. It is also failing to stop the anomalies in the sector,” he said, and observed that the new law will allow corruption to reign supreme and deficit to expand further.

“By only checking graft, the government can save Tk12,000 crore from the gas sector, Tk10,000 crore from power sector, and Tk1,000 crore from coal sector,” he said.

Continued gas and power tariff hike will take a heavy toll on the general people and badly impact the country’s economy, he warned.

Direct hit to daily life

Energy expert Badrul Imam said the government blatantly took the decision of amending the current law, despite knowing the consequences, mainly on poor and marginal people.

“Had there been enough gas exploration domestically, the government would not have to take the decision to repeatedly increase power and gas prices,” he said.

“Instead, the government focused on importing gas, thus, increasing expenditure, for which it needs a regular price adjustment. And that’s why the government turned to repeated tariff hikes,” Badrul added.

Economist Prof Anu Muhammad, also the member-secretary of National Committee to Protect Oil, Gas, Mineral Resources, Power and Port, said repeated price hikes will surely affect the daily life.

“Daily essentials will become pricier and so will our lifestyle. Productivity and competitiveness will also be affected,” he said.

He alleged that the government was willingly increasing expenditure in the power and energy sector, to serve the interest of local and foreign companies.

He also criticised the massive expansion in the power sector, saying: “Meeting target is not the main goal of the government; rather higher profit is.”

What government says

Following December 30 cabinet endorsement, Cabinet Secretary Khandker Anwarul Islam once the new law is passed BERC will be able to change the tariffs through a single or more orders once or more in a fiscal year if necessary.

“The tariffs can either rise or fall,” he said, but added that the rest of the provisions in the existing 2003 law were left unchanged.

Asked about the spiralling expenditure in the sector, State Minister for Power, Energy and Mineral Resources Nasrul Hamid on Thursday said there was no alternative to increasing the gas tariffs to adjust them to the prices of imported gas.

“But tariff hike once a year is a must in case of imported gas. It may even require two hikes to adjust the prices,” he said, referring to India, where he claimed power tariff changes every month.

Also, if gas becomes pricier, that will push up power tariff as well, he maintained.

Regarding the mammoth Tk15,000 crore capacity payment paid last year when a number of power plants were sitting idle, Nasrul said: “The sum had to be paid. We need to pay the money [capacity payment] for the power plants.

“We have to be ready for maximum output from the sector in future,” he said, and stressed that there was nothing to be worried about the new draft law.

Why the new law?

Bangladesh Oil, Gas and Mineral Resources Corporation, or Petrobangla, is planning to seek a Tk10,380 crore subsidy from the government to be able to continue the import of liquefied natural gas (LNG) in the current fiscal year.

The country has a daily demand of 3.70 billion cubic feet (bcf) gas, whereas the supply is around 2.70 bcf gas, and the demand is gradually growing.

Considering the situation, the government started importing expensive LNG from Qatar from April, 2018.

The situation in the power sector is even worse.

Bangladesh Power Development Board General Manager (commercial operation) Md Kausar Ameer Ali said they paid Tk15,000 crore to power plants for capacity payment last year, and the amount may shoot up to Tk20,000 crore this year.