A non-government research organisation has come up with an interesting finding that some of the smaller political parties have spent more money than the bigger ones in the January parliamentary elections.
Analysing the information that parties have provided and the Election Commission (EC) has put up on its website, the Election Working Group has found that the Workers Party of Bangladesh has spent more money per candidate than its bigger alliance partners Awami League and Jatiya Party (JaPa).
In the 10th parliamentary election held on January 5 which the BNP and the like-minded parties had boycotted, the Workers Party spent Tk2.85lakh on an average for each of its 18 candidates. On that count, the party spent a total of Tk51.31 lakh for election purpose.
For that election, in which at least 153 out of the 300 lawmakers were elected uncontested, HM Ershad’s JaPa also spent more money per candidate than its dominant partner Awami League.
Japa spent a total of Tk2.05 crore for its 86 candidates, averaging Tk2.38 lakh for each of them. The Awami League comes in next with a total expenditure of more than Tk2.53 crore for its 247 candidates, averaging only a little over Tk1.02 lakh for each.
These findings were made public yesterday by the Election Working Group in a policy paper titled “Bringing Transparency in Political Finance to Bangladesh” at a programme in the capital’s Cirdap Auditorium.
Among others, Awami League leader Mahbub-ul Alam Hanif, JaPa leader GM Quader, BNP leader Osman Farruk and TIB Executive Director Iftekharuzzaman were present at the programme.
The organisation also analysed the information available on the EC website regarding how much money the candidates have personally spent in the election.
In that comparison too, the Awami League candidates have been outclassed by JaPa and Workers Party runners.
JaPa contestants came out on top in this table, each personally spending over Tk16.97 lakh on an average, followed by Workers Party men, who spent over Tk10.15 lakh, and Awami League runners spending nearly Tk9.94 lakh on an average.
Their ally Jatiya Samajtantrick Dal, better known as Jasad, might have spent only a little over Tk4,000 for each of its 24 candidate; but the candidates’ average personal expenditure of Tk7.14 lakh was right up there.
Bangladesh Khelafat Majlish and Bangladesh Islami Front, two other small partners of the ruling alliance, did not spend any money for the election. They had two and one candidates for the election respectively and one of them were eventually elected.
Interestingly though, the three candidates of Tarikat Federation, another minor component of the Awami League-led alliance, personally spent more than Tk13 lakh on an average. Only the JaPa candidates have spent more than them.
When contacted, Workers Party President Rashed Khan Menon, also civil aviation and tourism minister, said there was no reason for his party’s per candidate election expenditure to be higher than those of the Awami League and JaPa.
“There must be something wrong with the figure...Is it possible? It cannot be. We gave [financial] support to our candidates from the party; but the personal expenditure of the candidates should not be like this,” he told the Dhaka Tribune.
When asked how a small party like the Workers Party could outclass its bigger allies, TIB ED Iftekharuzzaman told the Dhaka Tribune over phone: “Yes, it is abnormal. But credit goes to the Workers Party. They have probably submitted a truthful expenditure statement, while the other parties might have hidden their actual expenditures.”
In the first parliamentary election in 1973, the expenditure limit per candidate per constituency was Tk50,000. In this year’s 10th general election, the amount has been increased to Tk25 lakh.
As part of recommendations, the Election Working Group said public funding was essential for bringing transparency in election expenditure, disclosure provision must be made mandatory for parties and candidates during election campaign, and private donations along with sources must also be made public.
Just like most of the speakers, JaPa leader and former minister GM Quader also said the recommendations sounded good but were far from reality.
“The first thing we need to think is whether we want democracy in the country at all? Do we want to ensure transparency and accountability? I think we do not want those. All we want is to assume office by any means and misuse power. This is our politics and this is the reality,” Quader said at the programme.
Former BNP minister Osman Farruk said: “Politics should be based on donation. If donation stops, then politics will go into the hands of the rich and the businessmen...A strong Election Commission can prevent the entry of black money in politics. It is a reality that politics has become expensive.”
Awami League Joint General Secretary Mahbub-ul Alam Hanif said: “The necessity of money in politics cannot be denied. If we are ready to spend money for people, we are called generous. If we do not, we are labelled misers. That is the reality.”
While speaking at the programme, Iftekharuzzaman said: “In the first parliamentary election in 1973, only 17.5% members of parliament were businessmen. But that ratio has now gone up to 59%. That has happened because politics and the political parties are now being used as a means to becoming rich.”
Regarding state funding of election campaign, he said: “I am not convinced with this recommendation. I also doubt whether the country is ready for that. I am not even sure whether the people are ready to shoulder such burden. So before taking any such decision, I think there should be a referendum on it.”