Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina yesterday said her government would restore the provision of the original constitution to make the apex court judges accountable to the legislature, authorising the Jatiya Sangsad to impeach the judges for misconduct and violation of rules.
The 1972 constitution had the provision to make the judiciary accountable to parliament (subjected to vote of two-thirds majority), but military ruler General Ziaur Rahman changed the provision, changing Article 96 of the constitution.
He then transferred the power to the Supreme Judicial Council, headed by the chief justice, and comprising two other senior judges of the Supreme Court.
“Military ruler Ziaur Rahman formed the Supreme Judicial Council. This does not fit into democracy. This (accountability of the judiciary) should go to parliament as the representatives of the people. We are thinking about it (restoration of original article 96 of the constitution),” Sheikh Hasina told reporters at Ganabhaban, the official residence of the prime minister.
On June 26, the Law Commission, headed by immediate-past Chief Justice ABM Khairul Haque, placed a report on the ways of removing the backlog of the cases to the parliamentary standing committee on the law ministry.
The report proposed restoring the original provision of the first constitution, stating that all are equal in the eyes of the law. The watchdog discussed the report and asked the law minister to consult with all stakeholders to revive Article 96 of the charter.
Two weeks ago, standing committee chairman Suranjit Sengupta told media that the judiciary must be accountable to the legislature for ensuring the “sovereignty of parliament.”
While responding to a question at the press conference, Sheikh Hasina also said the Supreme Judicial Council had not adapted with parliamentary democracy.
“In 2010, when we formed a parliamentary committee for the amendment to the constitution after the repeal of the 5th amendment by the court, the issue of Supreme Judicial Council came up. And now, many, including the Law Commission and Human Rights Commission, have given their opinions against it,” she said.
As there is a democratic rule in the country, many are talking about reviving the article of 1972 constitution, she added.
Former Justice ATM Fazle Kabir cautiously welcomed Sheikh Hasina’s move to amend the constitution to replace the Supreme Judicial Council.
“It is my personal opinion that it is a political decision; we should not oppose it. This is practised in many countries. It also existed in Bangladesh,” he said.
“But the fear is that it may be misused by the governments,” he told the Dhaka Tribune. He said given the vituperative politics practised by the two major political parties, restoration of the provision would cause “huge damage.”
“For instance, a government, out of political vengeance, may victimise the judges appointed by the previous government. So, we should be very careful about it,” said Fazle Kabir, also a law commission member.
Senior lawyer Shahdeen Malik opposed the government move.
“The question of change arises when a system does not function properly or a major flaw surfaces. Hitherto, no allegation has come to the fore on the efficacy of the Supreme Judicial Council. So, it should not be changed.”
“So, there are questions about the functioning of the original provision,” he said, adding that the MPs were not free in making their decisions according to Article 70 of the constitution that forced a lawmaker not to vote against the respective party decisions in the legislature.
“In case a judge commits serious crime but the treasury bench lacks two-thirds majority, then the errant judge will not be punished unless the opposition or other parties agree,” he said.