Constitution expert Mahmudul Islam yesterday said the Representation of the People Order (RPO) provision, which allows declaring a lone candidate elected uncontested, was constitutional.
“The legal point, based on which the January 5 election was held, was correct. However, it was not ethically acceptable,” said Mahmudul, who was appointed by the High Court as an amici curia, which means an impartial adviser to the court, in this issue.
The former attorney general set forth his opinion before the bench of Justice Mirza Hussain Haider and Justice Khurshid Alam Sarkar.
He said: “The uncontested winner provision must exist. Many countries in the world have such provision. In the absence of such provision, if any major political party decides not to contest elections even though there is only one candidate, new election schedule has to be declared. Then it might happen that the party would again refrain from participating in the election. If such boycott is continued, it will lead to a vacuum.”
The bench set today to deliver its verdict on whether the RPO provision is constitutional or not. The court will also pass its judgement on a writ petition demanding inclusion of “no vote provision” in the RPO.
Mahmudul said: “The judiciary can direct the parliament only when the direction is based on constitution or law.”
He said the court could make any observation, if deemed necessary, in an appropriate case.
In a case of violation of fundamental rights, the High Court made an observation which prompted the parliament to amend the Public Service Retirement Act recently, said Mahmudul.
Additional Attorney General Murad Reza told the court to consider all possible consequences, including political, social and financial, before making any observation as every word of the court was very important.
“If the court thinks the petition that challenged the uncontested winner provision has no merit then it should not make any observation,” he said.
Mahmudul said the judicial review power of the Supreme Court could not be curtailed by anybody as that was an unchangeable feature of the constitution.
As for the inclusion of “yes/no vote” as the last resort when there is only one contender, the jurist said he was doubtful about whether the judiciary could deal with a matter of political wisdom.
Election Commission’s lawyer Tawhidul Islam said the commission had no authority to amend the RPO but the parliament could do so if it thought it was necessary.
However, the legislature could not be directed by the judiciary, he said, adding that the right to vote was a right created under the RPO rather than a constitutional one.
Following a writ petition filed on December 17 last year by Jatiya Party Vice-chairman Khandaker Abdus Salam, five amici curiae gave their opinions on the RPO provision that allows lone candidates to be elected unopposed. They are Dr Kamal Hossain, Badiul Alam Majumder, Barrister Rafique-Ul Huq, Ajmalul Hossain QC and Rokanuddin Mahmud.
Meanwhile, BNP standing committee member Barrister Moudud Ahmed withdrew his name as amicus curiae citing personal reasons.