If those votes were not cancelled...

Compared to the last upazila elections, the first phase of the elections this year saw a significant hike in the number of cancelled votes, which many said was “alarming” because these votes could have changed the results in some of the upazilas.

In the first phase this year, a total of 97 upazilas went into polls. In the last polls held in 2009, the number of cancelled votes in these 97 upazilas was 3.65%. This year, the number was 4.56%, marking a nearly 1% increase.

Election officials and observers said there were many reasons for cancelling votes: misplaced stamping on ballot papers; confusion between symbols; quality of ink used in the seal; lack of knowledge of first-time voters; and so on.

According to former election commissioner M Sakhawat Hossain, if not cancelled, such a huge number of votes “might” have had an impact on the results.

In the last elections, the number legal votes cast in these 97 upazilas was 98,95,320 while that of cancelled votes was 3,75,533.

This year, the number of legal votes was 96,52,584, while that of annulled votes was 4,61,383 – marking a rise of nearly 86,000.

“There is something definitely wrong. Our voters are neither that illiterate nor are all of them voting for the first time,” Sakhawat said.

Explaining why there were so many cancelled votes in the 2009 election, Sakhawat, who was then a commissioner, said the quality of the ink used was not very good; it took too much time to dry up.

Analysing the results of the recently concluded upazila polls, the Dhaka Tribune has found that in at least 12 closely contested upazilas, the number of annulled votes was much higher than the difference in votes got by the winners and the runners up.

In at least eight other seats, the number of cancelled votes was more or less equal to the difference in votes got by the top two contenders.

In 35 upazilas that went into polls last week, at least 5,000 votes were cancelled in each of them.

In Golapganj upazila in Sylhet, the number of cancelled votes was 5,565 while the difference between the winner and the next one was just 767.

In Khagrachhari sadar, the upazila that saw the hardest fight this year, the difference in vote was just 162 while the number cancelled votes was 1,637.

Rokhsana Khondker, steering committee member of the Election Working Group, said: “Definitely, the huge number of cancelled votes could have had an impact on the results, especially in those upazilas where the difference was less than the cancelled votes.”

A number of officials, who were directly involved in conducting the elections, told the Dhaka Tribune that there were many reasons why votes could get cancelled.

Nasima Khanam, assistant returning officer of Palash upazila in Narsingdhi, said votes could get cancelled if the seal fell on multiple symbols. “Voters’ carelessness also contribute such huge number of cancelled votes.”

Mohammad Rokab Ali Dewan, upazila election officer of Nachole in Chapainawabganj, said: “If those votes were not cancelled, the scenario could have been different. Then again, it does not mean that all the cancelled votes went to one particular candidate.”

Kamrul Hasan Bhuyan, presiding officer of the Kawra Government Primary School polling centre in Kendua of Netrakona, said 75 votes were cancelled in his centre.

“At my centre, voters got confused between the steamer and the aeroplane symbols because these two looked similar to many. Some of the votes were cancelled because the ballot papers were not properly folded and some got torn. Instances of the common problem of wrong or multiple stamping was also there,” Kamrul said.

According to Rokhsana Khondker, some of the first-time voters might not know how to vote. “It might also be the case that some people went to cast fake votes and made mistakes in a hurry.”

Former election commissioner Sakhawat Hossain said there should be proper investigation into why such a huge number of votes got cancelled. “There should be investigation into technical issues such as whether the voters were properly educated; the quality of the ink used in the stamp and the seal; spacing between symbols in ballot papers; and so on.”