Incomplete JS goes into session today

The 10th Jatiya Sangsad goes into its maiden session today without electing 50 women lawmakers to the reserved seats – a practice which many view as a violation of the constitution.

However, the law on electing women lawmakersto the reserved seats forces the authorities to convene an incomplete parliament.

The 10th parliament is set to start its first session with 296 lawmakers out of the total 300 elected by adult franchise.

The procedures of elections of women MPs stipulated in the Jatiya Sangsad (women’s reserved seats) Election Act-2004 compelled the Awami League to convene the 9th parliament on January 25, 2009 before they were elected.

Considered as the leading constitution expert in Bangladesh, Mahmudul Islam in his book Constitutional Law of Bangladesh said: “Even a single member of parliament could delay the sitting of parliament by not making and subscribing oath”.

Speaker Shirin Sharmin Chaudhury told the Dhaka Tribune: “The culture of taking women MPs (from the reserved seats) after the MPs elected from general seats is unlawful and discriminatory.”

She said the law on electing women to reserved seats “should be amended to stop discrimination against women”.

ShirinSharmin was elected MP to the reserved seat for women in the 9th parliament.

According to the article 65 of the charter, parliament must comprise of 350 members – 300 to be elected by direct popular votes from the same number of constituencies while 50 women MPs for the women’s reserved seats by those lawmakers.

The law passed by the BNP-Jamaat government says the political parties will get the share of the 50 women MPs according to their party strength in the legislature.

But the MPs elected from the general seats will elect women lawmakers in parliament if the parties nominate more candidates than the number a party deserves on the basis of its strength in parliament.

Since 2004, none of the parties have nominated candidates more than the fixed number of candidates for the parties having representation in parliament. But the women MPs came late.

“While the provision ofthe reserved seats was in place parliament could not sit unless the election to the reserved seats was held,” said Mahmudul Islam in his book.

“The election to the reserved seats could not wait on the ground that some persons elected to the general seats had not made and subscribed the oath as otherwise; even a single member of parliament could delay the sitting of parliament by not making and subscribing oath,” he said.

Dr Kamal Hossain, who was the chief of the constitution framing committee, told the Dhaka Tribune: “Mahmudul Islam’s views deserve respect.”

The election commission is yet to announce schedules for the election to the reserved seats.

The 2004 law says the election commission must prepare the list of all MPs elected from the general seats and demonstrate the list on the 31st working day since the publication of the gazette on MPs elected by the adult franchise.

The MPs cannot get elected without preparing and demonstrating the list of the MPs who would elect the women lawmakers.

Former chief election commissioner ATM Shamsul Huda said his commission elected the MPs to the reserved seats late due to the law related to the issue.

“According to the law, the women lawmakers will be elected by the directly elected MPs. So, unless we completed the electoral college, how can we elect the MPs,” he said while talking to the Dhaka Tribune.

He, however, said ideally all MPs should start their business simultaneously.

Senior Awami League MP Rahmat Alisaid: “According to the constitution, parliament should comprise of all MPs;there should not be any discrimination.”

He said unless the law is changed, convening parliament without the women MPs is ‘not illegitimate’.

According to the constitution, any law contradicting the constitution would turn ineffective.

The provision of the women’s reserved seats has been in the constitution since the creation of Bangladesh. The original constitution framed in 1972 had the provision of 15 women MPs from the reserved seats.

The party winning majority seats used to get all the reserved seats.

Military ruler Ziaur Rahman raised the number to 30 in 1979 making the provision in effect for the next 20 year and which was expired with the dissolution of the 7th parliament on July 13, 2001.

The Awami League government on June 17, 2000 tabled a bill proposing to increase the number of lawmakers for the reserved seats for women but failed to pass the bill as it lacked two-thirds majority in parliament, a provision necessary for any constitutional change.

In 2004, the BNP for the first time introduced the provision for the parties to get seats according to their party strength in direct votes raising the number of reserved seats for women to 45.

On September 3, 2005, the election commission published gazette on the women’s reserved seat.

The ninth parliament with Awami League’s three-fourths majority had its first session on January 25, 2009 while the official gazette on the 45 women reserved seats was published on March 24, 2009.

In all other parliaments since first one in 1973, the women MPs in reserved seats were elected before the JS went into first session as the majority party used to get all the seats.

But the BNP-led sixth parliament (election held in February, 1996), had no MPs from the reserved seats as the parliament was dissolved before it was properly formed.