The year 2019 could be summed up as a year of disappointments for the Bangladesh Nationalist Party as its goals for the year- secure party chief Khaleda Zia’s release from jail and launch movements for what it considers “restoring democracy” – have both failed.
The party was optimistic to win the 11th national polls. It allied with Dr Kamal Hossain’s Jatiya Oikya Front, but suffered an unprecedented defeat.
Despite the poor showings, the BNP made numerous plans to step up. However, their inability to hold major public events and failure to make a strong case for Khaleda Zia’s release has yielded the party nothing. All is quiet on the Jatiya Oikya Front too, indicating an alliance of convenience only. With acting chairman Tarique Rahman in exile for the past 11 years, the party appears to be in its worst state since the assassination of party founder Ziaur Rahman.
The question now is, will the party learn from its spectacular failures in 2019 or will it continue on the same vector in 2020?
Poor performance at the polls
The party has been out of power since 2006. It suffered a landslide defeat in the 2008 polls, boycotted the 2014 polls, threatened to boycott the sitting parliament after winning only six seats but joined anyway.
After the results came in, BNP unequivocally rejected the elections on December 30, 2018, bringing forward severe charges against supporters and party members including packing the ballot boxes with Awami League votes the night before.
The position of the BNP-led Jatiya Oikya Front, headed by Gono Forum President Dr Kamal Hossain remained the same. The Oikya Front secured eight seats in total – BNP six and Gono Forum two - in the 300-member parliament.
The BNP vehemently refused to join the parliament, but its handful of winners exposed conflicts within their ranks. Zahidur Rahman, elected from Thakurgaon-3, took oath as the first BNP lawmaker in the 11th parliament on April 27, 2019. The party promptly expelled him the same day.
Two days later, MPs-elect Harun Or Rashid, Aminul Islam, Ukil Abdus Sattar and Mosharraf Hossain also took the oath after the party reconsidered its position. Secretary General Mirza Fakhrul Islam Alamgir chose to bow out. Zahidur was later reinstated by the party.
Political commentator Prof Emazuddin Ahmed said: “The decision to join the parliament was the only good one this year, although belated. It will take a long time for them to turn around.”
Top BNP leaders told Dhaka Tribune that even though they could not “restore democracy” or free Khaleda Zia, they are winning new victories every day with increasing public support.
Leadership crisis
With Khaleda Zia serving a five-year sentence in prison, and Tarique Rahman, a fugitive, in London since 2008, Mirza Fakhrul has had to prevent the party from falling apart.
“There are no good or bad years in politics. We have been out of power for over 12 years. We need more time to restore democracy, which is our only political goal. We are following Tarique’s instructions. We are not hopeless, our failures were because of the constraints set by the government,” Mirza Fakhrul said.
Media reports have revealed that many BNP leaders and members are disgruntled with Tarique’s role, who is seldom seen in any political activity in the United Kingdom, but often dining out or attending apolitical celebrations.
Another commentator Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury said: “I do not see any concerns within BNP for their existence.”
One step ahead two steps back
The BNP claimed the government filed at least 4,098 cases against nearly 300,000 BNP members and arrested at least 4,300 activists before the 11th election alone.
Before the election, BNP sent a list of 1,046 “false cases” against its members to the Prime Minister’s Office, Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina promised to see the issue of false cases before election. But no progress was made.
“We campaigned for the release of Khaleda Zia and her rights to get bail. The government does not want her out,” said Selima Rahman, a member of BNP’s standing committee.
Amir Khasru Mahmud Chowdhury, another top BNP leader, said: “BNP supporters are losing jobs, the younger ones are not being employed because of their political affiliations.”
He also said, the party has, however, joined the upazila and Dhaka city polls in order to uphold the people’s interests.
Alliance of convenience
The BNP alliance with the Jatiya Oikya Front has not seen any coordinated political movement since the polls.
Mirza Fakhrul said: “We formed the Jatiya Oikya Front for the election. Now our focus is on strengthening the party, but we will work together again if it is necessary.”
Jatiya Oikya Front convener Dr Kamal Hossain said BNP’s role was to help in the grassroots movement across the country and they will continue doing that.