Two ministers face contempt ruling

The Supreme Court yesterday issued a contempt ruling against two cabinet members for expressing diatribes towards Chief Justice Surendra Kumar Sinha, a move believed to be unprecedented in the country's history.

Food Minister Qamrul Islam and Liberation War Affairs Minister AKM Mozammel Haque have been asked to reply by March 14 as to why they should not be prosecuted for the highly contemptuous comments they made recently.

They have also been ordered to appear before the court at 9am on March 15 to explain their comments over the appeal case of convicted war criminal Mir Quasem Ali. The ministers recently expressed doubt over the intention of the chief justice regarding the verdict in the case.

During the hearing on February 23, Justice SK Sinha criticised the International Crimes Tribunal prosecutors and investigation agency members involved in the case for negligence since they had failed to prove four charges brought against Quasem, the Chittagong commander of al-Badr force. He also flayed the government for not filing a case against Quasem even though it had the evidence that the war criminal had appointed lobbyists against the war crimes trial process.

The nine-member full bench of the Appellate Division led by the chief justice came up with the order on its own volition yesterday before the pronouncement of the judgement. The death sentence of Quasem, now a top financier of Jamaat-e-Islami, was upheld.

The bench said that the ministers’ comments, made at a discussion on March 5, had undermined the dignity and prestige of the Supreme Court and the chief justice’s office.

Shortly after all the nine judges had taken their seats, the chief justice told Attorney General Mahbubey Alam that they were astounded by the evil and contemptuous comments about the highest court of the country, which is thought to be naked interference on the independence of the judiciary.

Then the court came up with its order of issuing the contempt notice and summons of the two ministers.

Qamrul alleged that the chief justice was openly speaking in the language of the BNP, Jamaat-e-Islami and their lobbyists. He said that the appeal case should be reheard by a new Appellate Division bench excluding the chief justice. The other minister went even further, saying that the chief justice should not be delivering the verdict in the appeal case.

Their statements created a firestorm and earned massive criticism across the country. The matter was even discussed on TV talk shows. Later, the attorney general said that the ministers' comments were unexpected and unconstitutional. Mahbubey Alam also asked all to have faith in the judiciary, because it is a principal organ of the sate.

Mir Quasem’s chief counsel Khandker Mahbub Hossain and other BNP leaders described the comments as “an interference on the judiciary's independence” and demanded that they be prosecuted.

Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina herself in Monday's cabinet meeting slammed the two ministers for the comments, and said she and her government would not own such comments.

On Monday, a Supreme Court lawyer named Julfikar Ali issued a legal notice to the ministers, asking them to explain as to why their remarks would not be considered as contemptuous, unlawful and unconstitutional. Julfikar said he would file a writ petition if the ministers did not respond to the notices.

After yesterday's order, Mahbubey told reporters that the contempt ruling would not hamper the relation between the judiciary and the executive wings of the state.

“The prime minister has already said different organisations and individuals have been pretending that they are taking the war crimes trials ahead which is a wrong conception. The trial would have never taken place had this government not been in power and the prime minister taken firm stance,” he said.

In response to another query, Mahbubey said he had no idea whether it was the first time in the country's history that any minister was summoned by the top court, but one Habibullah Khan had been issued contempt ruling. He, however, could not recall the grounds or date of the ruling.

Qamrul to file time petition

Food Minister Qamrul, who was involved in the process of recruiting tribunal prosecutors and investigators, yesterday said he had made the remarks as a freedom fighter, not as a minister, and on behalf of the people of the country.

Qamrul said he would explain his stance to the court. “But I will be leaving for Malaysia today [Tuesday] on a government trip. I will come back on March 16 or 17. So I will seek for time through lawyers,” he told reporters at a press briefing at the Secretariat.

The other minister also said he would appear in court.

Law minister issues alert

Once again Law Minister Anisul Huq urged all not to make any statement regarding any sub-judice matter.

“The Supreme Court is an institution and the judges are part of it. It is not right to comment on a case pending with the judges,” Anisul told reporters at his office yesterday.

“The honour of the institution is hampered and damaged if any comment is made about a sub-judice matter. Subsequently, the honour of the country is damaged,” he said, but refrained from commenting on the contempt ruling issued against the ministers.