The counsel of condemned war criminal Motiur Rahman Nizami had prayed to the top court judges that the Jamaat-e-Islami chief gets lighter punishment.
The defence throughout the trial process also tried to establish that Nizami was not the “principal accused” but only collaborated with the Pakistani Army, and that he did not directly take part in the atrocities.
During the appeal hearing, senior Supreme Court lawyer Khandaker Mahbub Hossain prayed to the court that Nizami be spared from death sentence for his old age and for being an “Islamic scholar” and “gentleman.”
The defence relied on these arguments even though the International Crimes Tribunal in its verdict on October 29, 2014 clearly mentioned that despite being an Islamic scholar, al-Badr kingpin Nizami had misused his expertise in the Qur’an and Hadith during the 1971 Liberation War.
“Motiur Rahman Nizami along with other Jamaat-e-Islami leaders made a lot of inciting speeches to their young followers in public by giving wrong interpretation of religious injunctions for motivating the partymen to resist Indian agents and the miscreants [freedom fighters] at the cost of lives,” the tribunal said.
Nizami also “purposely treated Pakistan as the house of Allah in a meeting attended by the members of Islami Chhatra Sangha [now Chhatra Shibir] with an intent to infuse wrong conception about the house of Allah in the minds of the members of Islami Chhatra Sangha so that they can blindly counter the ‘miscreants’ [freedom fighters] and pro-liberation Bangalees treating them as enemies of Islam.”
“There is no denying that the accused was the then leader of Islami Chhatra Sangha who had education in Islamic religion. He is the writer of several Islamic books in which he depicted true Islamic attitude towards the non-Muslims.
“But while we go back to fateful 1971, the year of Liberation War, we find quite opposite picture in the deeds and thoughts of the accused and his associates including Prof Ghulam Azam, the then ameer of Jamaat-e-Islami,” the tribunal said.
The tribunal had observed that the citations like “Pakistan is the house of Allah,” “Hindus are always enemies of Muslims” and “Islam and Pakistan are one and indivisible,” may appear to be not so dangerous in its plain meaning.
But an evaluation of those speeches considering the prevailing circumstances and the Liberation War context was found dangerous as those were infused in the minds of young members of Razakar and al-Badr Bahini as gospel of truth. And on being inspired by those propaganda in the name of Islamic ideology, they committed more atrocities vigorously in collaboration with the Pakistani occupation forces.
The tribunal said: “If we consider the Qur’anic verses and the Hadiths, then there is no room to say that the acts of killing unarmed civilians, plundering their properties, infringing their fundamental rights, reigning coercive climate by causing physical and psychological harms in furtherance of common design and plan are compatible to the spirit of ‘Islam’ and ‘humanity.’
“... Thus, we are constrained to hold that Motiur Rahman Nizami being educated in Islamic education had consciously and also deliberately misused the name of the Almighty Allah and the holy religion ‘Islam’ in 1971 during the Liberation War of Bangladesh in order to ruin and root out the ‘Bangalee Nation.’”