The special train, initiated for transporting mangoes and sacrificial cattle from Chapainawabganj and Rajshahi, has been operating at a loss since its inception in 2020.
The west zone authority of Bangladesh Railway has reported a financial loss of Tk50 lakh in fuel costs alone over the past four years.
The special train service for transporting mangoes and cattle from these two districts is initiated every year to facilitate the farmers and traders so that they can easily transport their goods at a low cost.
However, due to certain challenges, mango farmers and cattle traders predominantly favor road transportation, resulting in financial losses for the special train service.
Meanwhile, railway authorities have clarified that the primary objective of initiating the train service was not profit-making, but to assist farmers and traders. They further emphasized the necessity for extensive awareness campaigns to educate these vital stakeholders about the train service's potential advantages.
3-year overview of earnings and losses
Sources from the office of the chief commercial manager of the western railway have revealed that from 2020 to 2023, the special train has transported 3,995 tons of mangoes and a total of 245 cows and 433 goats over the past three years.
This has generated an income of only Tk46.29 lakh, while the train's fuel expenses alone have amounted to nearly Tk92.91 lakh over four years. The train, thus, has incurred a net loss of Tk46.41 lakh in the past four years.
Cargo count in 3 years
The special mango train, which started operating on June 5-July 21, 2020, ran for 46 days and transported 1,200 tons of mangoes. No sacrificial animals were transported that year.
CourtesyThe following year, from May 27-July 15, 2021, the train ran for 50 days transporting 2,235 tons of mangoes.
In addition, the special cattle train transported 131 cows and 112 goats.
Last year, the special mango train ran for seven days from June 13-June 20, during which it transported 179 tons of mangoes while the special cattle train carried 36 cows and 160 goats.
This year, there was no special cattle train, but two extra wagons were added to the special mango train. The railway determined the fare for each wagon to be Tk11,830.
The train, operating from June 8-June 26 for 18 days, transported 382 tons of mangoes and, during Eid-ul-Azha, carried 78 cows and 161 goats.
Road transport preference
The railway authorities have clarified that the train was initiated not for profit but to serve the interests of farmers and traders.
However, farmers and traders have expressed a lack of interest in using the train.
Despite lower transport costs, the additional hassle of loading and unloading at the stations increases their overall transport expenses. As a result, they prefer to use road transport instead.
Abdus Samad, a cattle trader from Tanore Upazila in Rajshahi, highlighted specific challenges that prompt them to prefer road transport.
Courtesy“To board the train, the cattle must first be transported from home to the station using another vehicle. Then, they have to be taken off at the station and transported to the market using yet another vehicle. It is easier to avoid this hassle and take the cattle directly from home to the market using trucks,” he said.
Jahid Hasan, a mango trader from the Nowdapara area of Paba upazila in Rajshahi, said: "Even if the mangoes are transported by train for less money, the cost of transporting them twice with another vehicle becomes higher. Therefore, it is easier to transport mangoes by road. That is why we do not use trains."
Campaigning
Mehedi Hasan, a mango farmer from Chapainawabganj, said the cost of transporting mangoes by courier service is Tk12-Tk18 per kg. On the other hand, the cost of transporting the same quantity of mangoes in the special mango train is only Tk1.32.
“The government has been running this train at a loss for the past three years considering the convenience of mango growers and traders. However, extensive campaigning needs to be conducted to raise awareness among mango growers. Also, railway authorities should be contacted in advance by growers like us. Then there will be no loss of train services," he said.
Chapainawabganj Unnayan Parishad Member Secretary Moniruzzaman Monir said if the district administration and traders devise a specific plan on these issues during the mango season and Eid-ul-Azha, there will definitely be no loss.
"If there is no loss in courier service, why should there be a loss in the train service? Everyone has to work together to prevent this," he asked.
Rajshahi Sangram Parishad General Secretary said that the traders' issues with transporting mangoes and sacrificial animals by train need to be addressed.
“Extensive publicity needs to be run before the mango season and ahead of Eid-ul-Adha. There used to be a lot of loss in railway passenger transportation at one point, but now it is decreasing. So, transporting mangoes and sacrificial animals will also become popular over time. Therefore, everyone involved needs to work sincerely,” he added.
What does authority say?
Western Railway General Manager (GM) Asim Kumar Talukder said whether there is profit or loss, the government annually instructs to run this service to benefit farmers and traders.
“The government subsidizes many sectors for the public interest. This train service is somewhat similar. Moreover, we run publicity before starting the train,” he added.
The special mango train usually has seven wagons. Each wagon can transport 301 tons of mangoes. This train can carry mangoes from Chapainawabganj to Dhaka at a cost of Tk1.32 per kg and from Rajshahi to Dhaka at Tk1.17 per kg.