The Appellate Division has disposed of the governments appeal against the HC order declaring the existing Warrant of Precedence illegal.
The five-member appellate division bench headed by Chief Justice Md Muzammel Hossain issued the order with “expansions, modifications, observations and findings.”
According to the courts observations, the rank of chief Justice should be equivalent to that of the speaker of the national assembly, said Md Asaduzzaman, lawyer of the writ petitioner that yielded a 2010 HC order to issue a new Warrant of Precedence.
Asaduzzaman said the old warrant of precedence should be scrapped to formulate a new one in accordance with the Supreme Court order.
He said: “The posts of Appellate Division judges will be equivalent to cabinet ministers, while the HC judges will be equivalent to state ministers. The attorney general will be given precedence over secretaries.”
“MP’s will be given precedence over the cabinet secretary, chiefs of the armed forces and chief secretary. The post of additional attorney general will be equivalent to that of secretaries, and the posts of district judges will be equivalent to that of the administrative executives.”
Asaduzzaman said: “In our submission we said the current warrant of precedence was framed in an arbitrary manner. There was no objective satisfaction over it. As a result, the people formulating the warrant put someone anywhere they liked.
“We also said, no explanation was given to why the chief justice was excluded from equalling the rank of speaker in the reformed warrant of precedence of 1986 even though the posts were equivalent in the Warrant of Precedence of 1975.”
The existing Warrant of Precedence, formulated in 1986 and revised in 2008, ranks the speaker of the parliament in third, followed by the chief justice, and former presidents of Bangladesh in fourth positions.
On February 4, 2010, the High Court directed the government to issue a new Warrant of Precedence for the republic’s officers, giving district judges and equivalent judicial officers precedence over the chiefs of armed forces and government secretaries. The existing Warrant of Precedence was declared illegal and void, as it does not conform to the country’s constitution.
The government later appealed against the HC verdict.
The verdict came as a result of a 2006 writ petition challenging the legality of positioning the district judges and judicial officers lowest in the warrant of precedence. Md Ataur Rahman on behalf of Bangladesh Judicial Service Association filed the writ; Ataur is a former secretary general of the association, and a district judge.
The writ claimed that the cabinet division had framed the existing Warrant of Precedence in 1986 in an arbitrary manner, without evaluating the dignity and status of judicial officials.
During yesterdays hearing, Barristers Rokon Uddin Mahmud and Abdul Matin Khasru moved for the district judge and judicial officers, while advocate Abdur Rob Chowdhury moved for the cabinet and additional attorney general Murad Reja moved for the state side.