Warned by tribunal, Mizanul withdraws comment

A war crimes tribunal came down heavily on Mizanul Islam, a key defence lawyer representing Jamaat-e-Islami Nayeb-e-Ameer Abdus Sobhan, for criticising the country’s constitution during submission in the case yesterday.

Mizanul yesterday was placing closing arguments in the case against Subhan, who is facing nine charges of crimes against humanity committed in Pabna during the 1971 Liberation War.

The defence lawyer was earlier warned by the tribunal several times for misconduct and also fined for his repeated absence during proceedings. Latest on September 29, the tribunal 2 warned him of imposing fines for annoying the court.

Mizanul yesterday said: “I have completed my arguments. Before drawing conclusion, I want to say that the law tells about ensuring justice but the constitution bars to do so.”

Noticing his remark, Chairman of the International Crimes Tribunal 2 Justice Obaidul Hassan said: “You have said a terrible thing. The constitution is written at the cost of millions of martyrs who sacrificed their lives during the 1971 Liberation War. It reflects thoughts and opinions of the people and their elected representatives have formulated constitutions.”

Mizanul then acknowledged that he had uttered something “terrible.”

The tribunal chairman asked a bench officer to bring a copy of the constitution. Then he read out the preamble of constitution. Mizanul drew attention of the tribunal to article 47 (A) of the constitution.

Justice Obaidul said: “Yes, it says if anyone commits such and such offences, then certain rights will not be applicable for him. The constitution may deprive you from enjoying some rights but you cannot make such comment on the constitution. We will take action against you.”

Mizanul instantly said: “My lord, I am withdrawing my speech.”

Another member Justice Md Shahinur Islam said: “You should not have said this. You have made an extreme comment.”

The defence counsel then said: “My lord, this is perhaps my last argument before this tribunal. My prayer to the tribunal is that my 85-year-old client gets justice.”

Justice Obaidul said: “Justice is a right for everyone. He [Subhan] will get justice as per his rights. We are sitting here to uphold justice.”

The case proceeding was adjourned until Sunday when the defence will submit on the legal aspects.

The accused was indicted on December 31 last year. He faces different allegations including involvement in the killing of 400 Hindus.