Medical malpractice refers to certain criminal acts or omissions committed while clinically dealing with people seeking medical treatment. Such wrongful acts or omissions are committed by the physicians, surgeons, pharmacist, anesthesiologists, nurses, intern-doctors, medical assistants, hospital personnel or any other medical service provider either independently or, in rare cases, in furtherance of any common intention of all in pursuant to willful malpractice coupled with criminal negligence of both gross and culpable nature.
Medical malpractice is normally viewed as an actionable civil wrong, the remedy for which is generally pecuniary compensation. In common law jurisdictions, the notion comes within the purview of the law of torts, such as Malaysia, while some countries provide for separate legislation with specific judicial forum to redress such wrong, eg in India, medical malpractice cses are adjudicated under the Consumer Protection Act. Medical malpractice coupled with criminal negligence generally gives rise to a criminal offence and is generally dealt with by the criminal law of any given country.
Doctrine of medical malpractice
Medical Malpractice is generally defined as “Mistreatment of a disease or injury through ignorance, carelessness or criminal intent.” It is the negligent or incorrect performance of the professional duties of doctors, health care providers such as, nurses and institutions including hospitals. It is a departure by a physician or hospital from accepted levels of medical care. Medical Malpractice usually results in harm, injury, distress, prolonged physical or mental suffering, or the termination of life of a patient.
Examining the medical malpractice in the touchstone of criminal jurisprudence
It is expected that a medical professionals show a fair, reasonable and competent degree of skill. It is important for a medical practitioner to remember that negligence involving the risk of injury is punishable criminally, though nobody is actually hurt by it. The mere act of exposing a patient to the risk of personal safety or life is enough to trigger a criminal negligence case.
Negligence is one of the wrongs for which the law gives a remedy both under the civil law and the criminal law. Penal liability is commonly based on the co-existence of two conditions – material and formal. Material condition implies two requisites: an act must have been done and the act must have been done by the person to be held liable. The other is the mens rea or a guilty mind with which the act has been done.
Therefore, before the law can justly punish a criminal act, an inquiry must be done into the mental attitude of the doer for although the act may have been objectively wrongful, the mind of the doer may have been innocent. The mental attitude of the medical practitioner would thus have to concur with the wrongful act before he could be prosecuted successfully under the criminal law.
To attribute mens rea to a wrongful act it is necessary that the act be done either willfully or recklessly. If a medical practitioner does an act which he did not foresee, but which a reasonable medical practitioner would have foreseen under similar circumstances as likely to cause injury, he/she would be held guilty of the wrongful act. Here “foreseen” and “foreseeable” consequences are put on the same footing as consequences which are intended.
Criminal negligence is the gross or culpable neglect, or failure to exercise that reasonable or proper care and precaution to guard against an injury which was an imperative duty of the concerned professional to adopt. Medical negligence is a gross negligence (culpa lata) which differ from slight negligence (culpa levis).
Modern jurists and medico-legal experts differentiate between negligence and error in their judgments.
Leaving ‘foreign body’ in patient’s body by surgical error
Occasionally, sponges, clothes stained with blood (making them difficult to see) and surgical instruments are left inside the body of a patient. These objects can cause infections and lesions and require painful and risky revision surgery to remove those objects. Medical malpractice can involve serious errors as wrong-site surgery, labour mismanagement, a substandard procedure, or other gross mistakes.
Surgical errors are also common. Anaesthesia reactions and problems cause many deaths and injuries each year as well as failure to properly monitor a patient during and after a surgery causes grievous physical impairment which are irreparable.
Onus of proof in a medical malpractice litigation
In order to prevail in a Medical Malpractice claim, the plaintiff must prove four elements as enunciated in the Four Elements of Medical Malpractice, Yale New Haven Medical Center:
I. That the defendant owed the plaintiff a duty of reasonable care
II. That the negligent care was rendered
III. That the plaintiff incurred an injury, loss or harm, and
IV. That the damage or harm done to the patient was a direct result of the negligent care.
The plaintiff must prove each of these four elements by a preponderance of the evidence.
Degree of criminal liability in a medical malpractice litigation
So far as the spirit of the penal law regarding the principle of joint liability is concerned the criminal responsibility of all the persons committing the malpractice is equal in the eye of criminal law who had participated in the occurrence in furtherance of the common intention of all. That is why all the persons allegedly engaged in the process of medical mistreatment or surgical operation including the surgeon, fellow physicians, anesthesiologists, nurses and hospital personnel in any given criminal action shall come within the periphery of the criminal responsibility of the alleged offences committed by them in furtherance of their common intention.
Feasible judicial action for medical malpractice
Criminal prosecutions
Arguably, the exemptions and immunities given for the defence of “good faith doctrine” in sections 88 and 92 of the Penal Code narrowed the scope for criminal action against medical malpractice in Bangladesh. However, it can be argued that in such cases mens rea need not be proved, or alternatively, instead of actual guilty mind, knowledge of the probable injury or constructive mens rea should suffice.
Civil prosecutions
Since there is no express or implied restriction in any other law for the time being in force in Bangladesh, civil suits for compensation are largely maintainable in accordance with sections 9 and 19 of the Code of Civil Procedure (1908) for all instances of medical malpractices.
Consumer rights prosecutions
Since the medical profession comes within the meaning of “service” as defined in the Consumer Protection Act, compensations can be achieved under this Act for the damage caused due to negligence in the delivery of the service.
Judicial review
Apart from providing remedy where there is no other equally efficacious remedy obtainable under the domestic law, judicial review can also offer prospective collective remedy or open the sealed doors of procedural relief. Judicial review, in the form of Public Interest Litigation or in other cases, can provide certain remedy regarding medical negligence. The remedy bestowed by judicial review may not directly benefit an individual, but it does have a collective impact on any such issue of popular significance.