Writ challenges legality of 16th amendment

A Supreme Court lawyer has filed a writ petition with the High Court challenging legality of 16th amendment of the constitution that restored parliament’s authority to impeach the SC judges for misconduct and incapability.

Supreme Court lawyer Eunus Ali Akond filed the petition on Wednesday afternoon.

He urged the court to issue a rule upon the government seeking an explanation as to why the amendment should not be declared illegal and to adjourn the effectiveness of the amendment until the hearing.

He also requested the court to direct the government to cancel the 16th amendment to the constitution.

In his petition, Eunus Ali Akond said: “According to section 66 of the constitution, no specific academic qualification is fixed to hold the position of MPs. But as per section 95, a lawyer or a district judge needs 10 years’ experience to become a SC judge. So how can they have the authority to impeach judges?”

He said: “It is totally repugnant of the constitution as the president has the authority to appoint judges as per section 135(1).”

The independence of the judiciary will be diminished, if the power to impeach SC judges is given to the parliament, he added.

On September 17, the parliament passed the amendment bill rejecting all calls for imploring public opinion.

President Md Abdul Hamid gave his consent to the 16th Amendment bill on September 22.

According to the amendment, not only the judges, parliament can also remove the chief election commissioner and commissioners of the Election Commission, the chairman and the members of the Public Service Commission, chairmen and the commissioners of the Anti-Corruption Commission, and the Comptroller and Auditor General on similar grounds.

The articles establishing the Election Commission, Public Service Commission, the Anti-Corruption Commission, and the office of the Comptroller and Auditor General stipulate that the holders of constitutional posts would be removed according to the procedures applicable for the removal of the Supreme Court judges.

The original constitution of 1972 contained the provision for impeachment of the judges by a two-third majority in parliament.