Freedom of expression or right to reputation?

Defamation is defined both as a civil wrong and a criminal offence in the legal regime of various states. In legal words, a person can either be sued for compensation by the affected person, or be criminally prosecuted by the state. Arguably, the notion of criminal defamation is viewed as legally unfounded as it stipulates a disproportionate punishment and has a ruthless effect on freedom of expression.

Statutory definition of defamation provided in the Penal Code of 1860 under Section 499, says that whoever, by words, signs, or by visible representations, makes or publishes any imputation concerning any person intending to harm the reputation or such person, is said, barring exceptions, to defame that person.

Arguments in defamation cases In defamation prosecutions, the accuser usually argues that the contents of any report published in any given printed publication in relation to him/her is not only false, baseless and concocted but also scandalous, disgraceful and defamatory which lowered his/her social and professional status in the estimation of the people of his/her environs. Hence, the persons publishing defamatory statement should be charged with the offence of defamation they have committed. It is alleged that along with the principal accused ie the writer, the publisher of the said printed publication is also responsible for defamatory matter published in such paper whether he knows the contents of such writing or not. Moreover, in such a case, generally the editor of the printed publication is bound to take due care and caution before a libelous statement goes for final publication under his/her supervision. Therefore, all the personnel concerned with the said publication are equally liable for publishing such imputation as contained in the alleged writing intending to harm the reputation of the person alleged to have been defamed.

The contrary argument in defamation cases includes mainly a legitimate standpoint upon which the accused persons solicits exemption from the criminal liabilities of the allegations brought against them. The argument stipulates that in pursuant to the first exception of Section 499 of the Penal Code, it is not a defamation to impute anything which is true concerning any person, if it be for the public good that the imputation should be made or published. Therefore, the alleged accused persons claim that they do not incur any criminal liability for publishing something in good faith which public good requires.

Question of fact and question of law It is to be noted that whether publication of something is for the public good or not is a question of fact. It is invariably argued by the plaintiffs of defamation cases that the provisions of CrPC regarding the framing of charge enumerates that at the initiation of a criminal trial (at the time of charge-framing) it is the question of law which is to be decided. The question of fact can be decided and entertained along with the question of law as the trial procedure advances to the evidence recording stage.

Free speech vs privilege of dignity Criminal defamation laws are somewhat complicated from the point of view of freedom of expression and allied rights. They can lead to the imposition of harsh sanctions, such as a prison sentence, suspension of the freedom of expression, or a heavy fine. Even if they are applied with moderation, criminal defamation laws still cast a long shadow: the possibility of being arrested by the police, held in detention and subjected to a criminal trial will be in the back of the mind of a writer when he or she is deciding whether to expose, for example, a case of high-level corruption, moral turpitude and gross misappropriation, etc. This is not to say that prosecution for defamation should be discouraged; but, the means used to discourage it should be carefully targeted to prevent the dampening of legitimate criticism. In some instances it is seen that affluent or politically powerful individuals and corporations have instituted defamation cases, even where they have no prospect of success, with a view to preventing media criticism of their questioned dealings.

It is widely recognised that the making of certain statements which the author is under duty to make, or has a specific interest in making has been protected unless it has been done maliciously. The contemporaneous international trend for defamation law discourse is to interpret the scope of this protection broadly, given the particular importance of freedom of expression on these occasions.

The law of defamation reflects the conflict of two fundamental rights: the right to freedom of expression, including freedom of the media, and the right to reputation. The rules of defamation law are intended to mediate between these two rights. The defamation law discourse flows from the analysis of the rights in issue; the value underlying the right to reputation is human dignity, while the value that is most pertinent to freedom of expression in this context is the argument that free speech is integral to democracy.

The argument from democracy emphasises that speech on matters of public interest should receive greater protection than private speech. In particular, the presumptions that defamatory allegations are false and have caused damage, the principle of strict liability to primary publishers and negligence liability to secondary publishers, and the availability of punitive damages, should not survive constitutional inspection.

The quantum of damages and costs rules, and the remedies available in defamation cases, should also be reformed to reflect the significance of dignity of the claimant, and the free speech interest of the public in receiving true information on matters of public interest and public policy.