The agonising wait of millions of justice seekers and victims of 1971 war crimes ended yesterday with a shock as the Supreme Court in the appeals case of Delawar Hossain Sayedee handed down imprisonment until natural death overturning the death sentence given by the tribunal.
Frustrated by the apex court verdict, they promptly raised question why the death sentence was not upheld even though apex court had found the Jamaat-e-Islami leader guilty of most heinous war crimes, genocide and crimes against humanity.
“I am very shocked at the verdict,” a victim of Sayedee’s war crimes, Gouranga Chandra Das, 69, said when contacted over phone for his reaction to the verdict.
“What else have I to say after the Supreme Court’s final verdict? Now I have nothing to expect, except for my death,” he told the Dhaka Tribune.
Majority judges of the five-member apex court bench found 74-year-old Sayedee guilty of murder, abduction, confinement, torture, rape, persecution and abetement of torture, looting, forceful religious conversions and setting homes ablaze in rural areas of his home district Pirojpur during the war.
Now in the condemned cell of Kashimpur Jail, the war criminal was found to be relieved possibly after learning about the verdict, say officials. After the copy of the verdict reached the jail authorities, he will be shifted from the condemned cell, where death row convicts are kept.
Out of the 20 charges brought against Sayedee, the International Crimes Tribunal 1 found him guilty in eight. As the tribunal gave him death sentences in two charges, it did not give any punishment in the six other charges. Against the judgement, Sayedee appealed for acquittal while the state sought punishment in the six proven charges.
Of the eight charges, the Supreme Court, by a majority, convicted Sayedee in four charges and partially in another. The court acquitted him in three charges and part of another charge.
The apex court gave Sayedee imprisonment until death in charges 10, 16 and 19. “Imprisonment for the rest of his natural life,” Chief Justice Md Muzammel Hossain said during the pronouncement of the short verdict.
Sayedee’s death penalty in charge 10 was commuted to life imprisonment. Though found guilty, he had not been given any punishment in charges 16 and 19 by the tribunal.
In the other one and a partial charge, the majority of judges of the bench gave Sayedee 10 and 12 years’ rigorous imprisonment.
Of these, the tribunal awarded him the death sentence in charge number eight, which has two sections – the killing of Ibrahim Kutti, and the abduction and torture of Mofizuddin Poshari. In this, by a majority, the apex court altered the death sentence to 12 years’ rigorous imprisonment and acquitted the war criminal in another part.
The Appellate Division awarded Sayedee 10 years’ rigorous imprisonment in charge number seven, which was proved but not punished by the tribunal.
The chief justice did not elaborate on the difference in judgement during the pronouncement of the verdict.
But later on, many lawyers in the court were seen talking among themselves on this issue.
They said three of the five judges – the chief justice, Justice SK Sinha and Justice Hasan Foez Siddique – gave Sayedee life imprisonment. Of the two other judges, Justice AHM Shamsuddin Choudhury Manik awarded Sayedee death sentence while Justice MA Wahhab Miah acquitted him.
Specific information in this regard will be known officially when the full judgement is released, the lawyers said.
After the verdict Attorney General Mahbubey Alam said: “I hoped the death sentence given by the tribunal would be upheld. I feel sorry since it did not happen.”
Sayedee’s one is the second verdict by the Appellate Division bench in war crimes appeals cases. In its maiden verdict, the court enhanced the punishment of another notorious war criminal Abdul Quader Molla. The Jamaat leader was awarded life-term imprisonment by the International Crimes Tribunal 2.
Though Quader Molla’s case was the first one disposed of by the apex court and he was executed in December, Sayedee’s case was the first war crimes case to get rolling at the tribunal.
A notorious war criminal and Jamaat’s Nayeb-e-Ameer (vice-president) Sayedee was a 30-year-old grocer in 1971. He was not involved in politics during the war. He could speak Urdu well as he had obtained an Alim degree from a madrasa.
At Parerhat Bazar of Pirojpur, Sayedee welcomed the Pakistani army which along with its local collaborators killed more than three million Bangalees and raped over 250,000 women. More than 10 million people had to flee to India to take refuge while millions of others were displaced inside the country.
Sayedee himself converted Gouranga, who still lives in Parerhat, his other family members and many others from Hinduism to Islam saying that it was a requirement to stay in the then East Pakistan.
Sayedee also tortured and violated many Hindu girls, said Gouranga, who was one of the witnesses in the case.
The old man is now in severe hardship. He said: “I have no earning source. My wife died months back while suffering from fear that we may be victimised again as I gave deposition against Sayedee.
“I am not happy after learning about the verdict. He [Sayedee] should have been sentenced to death for committing heinous crimes,” he said. “My comments have no meaning now, everything is over.”
“Tell the prime minister about my hardship and wounds over the Supreme Court verdict, and ask the prime minster to ease my pains,” he said.
In a packed court room, the chief justice pronounced the sentence within a few minutes of commencing business at 10:07am. The five judges sat on the bench two minutes before starting the pronouncement of the short verdict.
More than an hour-long wait of several hundred people including lawyers, journalists, justice seekers, local and foreign observers and Sayedee’s son in the court room, there were some fresh speculations at the last minute about the outcome of the legal battle which began 18 months ago when Sayedee’s appeal was filed.
Following the tribunal verdict on February 28 last year, Jamaat and its student wing Islami Chhatra Shibir and Sayedee’s followers orchestrated widespread violence in many parts of the country for several days, killing dozens of people and destroying public and private property.
But after the verdict yesterday, it was relatively calm. Many Jamaat lawyers, who were involved in the case, and Sayedee’s son Masood Sayedee, who was present in the courtroom, seemed visibly relieved as they smiled and shook hands with each other.
However, Maood Sayedee told the Dhaka Tribune: “We did not get the expected verdict. We expected his acquittal from all the charges. We will file a petition for reviewing the judgement.”
However, the attorney general said he would not appeal for a review.
There is fear that if the incumbent government is changed, the convicted war criminal might get released from jail through presidential mercy or other means.
According to Attorney General Mahbubey, no government can act against this judgement to make him free if people remain alert about war criminals.
In late March last year, Sayedee filed an appeal with the Supreme Court seeking acquittal from all the charges. On the other hand, the state on behalf of the victims of Sayedee’s crimes filed an appeal petition pleading to uphold the tribunal’s death sentence and also to punish him on the six proven charges in which the tribunal did not give any sentence.
The chief justice yesterday said the judges had allowed both appeals in part by majority.
Sayedee, according to the tribunal judgement, was a member of the razakar force – an auxiliary force of the Pakistani Army, and formed the local Peace Committee during the war. Known as Deilya Razakar at that time, he actively took part in atrocities on civilians, Hindus and the pro-liberation people committed by Pakistani occupation forces and the razakars.
Elected as a lawmaker twice – during 1996-2001 and 2001-2006 terms, Sayedee is also known for his religious sermons (waaz) in and outside the country. He has a few thousand fans. He uses titles like “Allama” and “Maulana.”
Speculations and rumours over the final verdict were mounting up as it took more than a year to complete the appeals hearing. Since Sayedee filed the appeal at the end of March last year while the verdict remained pending for the last five months.
The apex court had disposed of the first appeals case of Quader Molla in six months.
High security measures were taken on and around the Supreme Court premises as well as across the country to ensure security, keeping in mind the atrocities Jamaat-Shibir men had carried out after the tribunal’s verdict.
Except for some scattered incidents of vandalism, the situation remained relatively calm yesterday, though the Jamaat has called a hartal for today and Sunday in protest against the verdict.
Three charges: Jail until death
Though the tribunal awarded the death sentence in charge 10, the apex court commuted the punishment to imprisonment until death. On June 2, 1971, Sayedee’s armed associates, under his leadership and accompanied by the Pakistani Army, burnt 25 houses at a Hindu locality in Umedpur village under Indurkani police station. At one stage, a victim, Bisabali, was tied to a coconut tree and was shot dead by Sayedee’s accomplices.
In charge 16, the tribunal found Sayedee guilty but did not specify any punishment.
In the course of the war, Sayedee led a group of 10 to 12 armed razakars and Peace Committee members who surrounded the house of Gouranga Saha of Parerhat Bandar under Pirojpur sadar. Subsequently, Sayedee and the others abducted three women and handed them over to the Pakistani Army in Pirojpur where the victims had been confined and raped for three days before being released.
Similarly, in charge 19, Sayedee was found guilty, but the tribunal did not give any punishment.
During the war, Sayedee, being a member of the razakar force and exercising his power over the Hindu community of Pirojpur, converted 100 to 150 Hindus of Parerhat and other villages to Islam, and compelled them to go to the mosque to offer prayers.
Jail in different terms in one and a half charges
The tribunal had given Sayedee death sentence in charge number eight but the Appellate Division altered it to 12-years’ rigorous imprisonment in a part of this charge. The court in another part of the charge acquitted Sayedee. However, it did not pronounce the two parts separately. Court sources say the Jamaat leader was acquitted in the charge of killing Ibrahim Kutti while sentenced for the abduction and torture of Mofiz Poshari.
On May 8, 1971, Sayedee and his accomplices accompanied by the Pakistani Army raided the house of one Manik Posari at Chitholia under Pirojpur sadar and caught his brother Mofizuddin and one Ibrahim Kutti. The attackers torched five houses there. On the way to the Pakistani Army camp, Sayedee instigated the members of the occupation force to kill Ibrahim by gunshot and dump his body near a bridge. On the other hand, Mofizuddin was taken to the camp and tortured.
In charge number seven, the tribunal found Sayedee guilty but did not specify punishment. The Appellate Division bench gave Sayedee 10-years’ rigorous imprisonment.
On May 8, 1971, Sayedee led a team of the Pakistani Army to the house of Nurul Islam Khan and identified him as an Awami League leader and his son Shahidul Islam Selim as a freedom fighter. Sayedee captured Nurul and handed him over to the army personnel, who tortured him. His house was then looted and finally set on fire.