Defence argument ends in Azhar case

After submitting for nine sessions, the defence for Jamaat-e-Islami leader ATM Azharul Islam yesterday concluded placing arguments at the International Crimes Tribunal 1.

The three-member tribunal, led by Justice M Enayetur Rahim, later adjourned the hearing until September 18 accepting a time plea of the prosecution. On September 11, the tribunal asked the prosecution to prepare for placing rebuttal arguments after the end of defence argument.

While arguing on the prosecution plea for compensating a rape victim, defence counsel Shishir Monir claimed that there was no provision of compensation in the penal code.

He said: “I have scrutinised each section of the penal code. There is provision of fines, but not compensation. It ultimately goes against the tribunal law.”

On charge four, he said one prosecution witness had seen Azhar standing in front of their house.

It does not mean the accused had been involved in abetting the abduction and killing of teachers of Rangpur Carmichael College.

The counsel also submitted on contradictions in testimonies of prosecution witnesses.

On labelling the Rangpur Town Hall as a torture camp, Shishir argued that only one judge among the three knew about it, “which means the use of Rangpur Town Hall as a torture camp is not a matter of common knowledge and cannot be taken into judicial notice.” 

The prosecution concluded their part of arguments on August 26, seeking death penalty for Azhar. A total of 19 witnesses testified against the accused. Of them, the prosecution declared their seventh witness hostile. The defence produced a relative of Azhar to testify in his favour.

According to the case, Azhar, now 61, was a commander of Rangpur district unit of al-Badr during the war. He was arrested on August 23, 2012. The tribunal indicted him on November 12 last year on six specific charges of crimes against humanity.

Last witness in Subhan case

After the end of deposition of prosecution’s 29th witness yesterday, the prosecution in the case against Jamaat Nayeb-e-Ameer Maulana Abdus Subhan said they would place the investigation officer on the next hearing date.

Freedom fighter SK Shahidullah, 68, from Nishchintapur village in Sujanagar of Pabna, told the tribunal 2 that the accused had participated in the atrocities that took place in five villages on May 12, 1971.

“On that day, a combined attack was carried out in five villages in our locality. That morning, I saw the Pakistani Army taking people to Nishchintapur Primary School ground. When I entered my house my mother said they also took my elder brother Obaidullah.”

The witness went to the spot and saw two army vehicles and one white car parked in front of the school. The car was used by Subhan, then chairman of Peace Committee and acting ameer of Jamaat in Pabna.

After the army had left the area around 3pm, Shahidullah met five people at Fatikpur carrying his wounded brother. He told the tribunal that Obaidullah was still alive. The witness also described the killings of his cousins Moni and Entaz, and another Saken.

Subhan’s lawyer Mizanul Islam later cross examined him and the three-member tribunal led by Justice Obaidul Hassan adjourned the proceedings until today.