AG, defence face SC wrath for slack preparation

Two judges of a four-member bench of the Appellate Division yesterday reprimanded the attorney general and defence counsel of convicted war criminal Muhammad Kamaruzzaman as they were not prepared for the hearing.

The court sat at 9am on the 13th day of hearing in the appeal case, which appealed the International Crimes Tribunal verdict handing down a death sentence to the Jamaat-e-Islami leader.

The defence commenced arguments on the fourth and seventh charges in the case around 9:30am before the bench headed by Justice Sunrendra Kumar Sinha.

During the hearing, defence counsel SM Shahjahan failed to properly present his case. He was stumbling when the judges queried on different issues of his argument.

In charge four, Kamaruzzaman was handed a death sentence for killing Golam Mustofa of Sherpur during the 1971 Liberation War. He was given a life sentence for killing Dara Mia of Mymensingh in charge seven.

Shahjahan finished presenting arguments around noon. The court then asked Attorney General Mahbubey Alam to present the state’s side.

As Mahbubey sought adjournment for hearings yesterday and today, Justice SK Sinha said: “If we adjourn the argument session, we will forget it later. Our head is not a computer.”

The attorney general then looked for his assistant who was not present in the court at the time. The judge then wanted to know the name of his assistant.

As Mahbubey replied that it was Deputy Attorney General Bashir Ahmed, another judge Md Abdul Wahhab Miah said he had seen Bashir earlier sitting idle on the prosecution bench.

Terming Mahbubey an “all-rounder,” Justice Sinha said: “Writ, civil, company, crime...you conduct everything. The Bangladesh government finds you as the only lawyer who knows everything. You can bag more than three-fourths vote, but you cannot collect a few lawyers. This is a pathetic situation.”

“Previously, we conducted many sensational cases where we found lots of good lawyers. But they are all keeping aloof with the passage of time. We only have one [the attorney general]. This is not a good sign.”

The judge then told defence lawyer Shahjahan: “You must submit written arguments by tomorrow [today]. I asked for it before. I am personally I am not satisfied with your argument.”

The defence lawyer replied that he would submit the documents by today.

Justice Wahhab Miah told Shahjahan: “In the eyes of the law, 100 accused may be acquitted, but one innocent person should not be punished. Maybe he [Kamaruzzaman] is charged for very heinous crimes, but when you come [to the court] to defend him, you should be fully prepared.”

He also said as per the law, the defence was supposed to prove that the tribunal judgement was wrong. “But you could not do so.”

Addressing both Shahjahan and Mahbubey, the judge said: “Do you want to put all the burden on us? Do we have to do everything for you?”

Bashir arrived at the court just then.

The attorney general at 12:26pm started hearing on charge one where Kamaruzzaman was given lifetime imprisonment. It is related to the abduction and killing of Bodiuzzaman of Nalitabari in Sherpur.

Mahbubey too stumbled in his arguments, failing to answer properly the queries posed by the court.

Before his arguments began, Justice Sinha expressed frustration over the war crimes tribunals’ activities. “There is no court in Bangladesh where so much money is spent. Why then is your condition so dismal?

“You have utilised six judges of the High Court [to the tribunal] of whom M Enayetur Rahim and [Obaidul Hassan] Shahin are very brilliant. I know them personally.”

The court said that the absence of these judges have caused a set back to the High Court.

Justice Sinha said: “When the [tribunal] prosecutors are on television, they talk a lot...they even tilt their heads to ensure that they are seen on screen. But when it comes to paper, there are no similarities [with their speech on TV]. We can now see what they actually do.”

The court adjourned for the day at 1pm.

Justice Sinha told the attorney general: “The hearing will start tomorrow [today] again. Be well-prepared when you come to court.”

Mahbubey again sought adjournment for one more day, but the judges turned down his plea and left the court.

The tribunal 2 on May 9 last year sentenced Kamaruzzaman, one of the key organisers of infamous al-Badr force, to death after finding him guilty of committing crimes against humanity. The Jamaat leader filed the appeal on June 6 last year seeking acquittal.