With four cases kept for verdict with the two International Crimes Tribunals and an appeal case pending for verdict at the Supreme Court for months, campaigners have expressed frustration and raised questions about the trial processes.
As of today, four cases – against Jamaat chief Motiur Rahman Nizami, former BNP leader Jahid Hossain Kokhon, former Awami League leader Mobarak Hossain and Jamaat leader Mir Kashem Ali – are awaiting verdict at the tribunals.
The appeal case of Jamaat Nayeb-e-Ameer Delawar Hossain Sayedee, who was sentenced to death by the tribunal, has been kept pending for verdict by the apex court.
Around nine months have passed since any of the two tribunals has pronounced a verdict in the war crimes cases. In October last year, the tribunal delivered verdict against absconding Chowdhury Mueen Uddin and Ashrafuzzaman Khan.
The case against Nizami has been kept for verdict three times so far because of unavoidable reasons. The first time hearing in this case ended in November 2013. But the tribunal chairman went into retirement keeping the verdict pending.
In February, the reformed tribunal started rehearing the arguments and in March, marked the case CAV (curia advisari vult meaning keeping the verdict waiting until a later date). The verdict was put off again in June when the accused fell ill.
The cases against Mir Kashem Ali has been kept CAV in May, Jahid Hossain Kokhon in April and that against Mobarak Hossain has been pending verdict since June.
In April, the Supreme Court kept the appeal case of convicted war criminal Delawar Hossain Sayedee CAV after hearing for 50 working days. He was sentenced to death by the International Crimes Tribunal in February last year.
In contrast, with around a year taken in the case of Sayedee, the apex court took only two months to settle the appeal of Jamaat stalwart Quader Molla, who was hanged in December last year.
Trial of Jamaat-e-Islami as a criminal organisation appears to be uncertain especially after the law minister had said the trial could not be conducted under the existing laws. The probe body of the tribunal submitted its report in March this year.
The first tribunal kept the case CAV for three months to pronounce verdict against Razakar kingpin and former Jamaat chief Ghulam Azam. The tribunal took just two months to pronounce verdict against Sayedee.
Prosecution witness Shyamoli Nasreen, the wife of a Liberation War martyr, said the opportunity to testify against the accused war criminals was a privilege for her. But the elongated periods of wait for verdict have frustrated her.
“We had to wait too long for the trials to start. We cannot bear the delay anymore,” Shyamoli said.
Writer Shahriar Kabir, who has been spearheading the nationwide campaign for the trial of war criminals, is frustrated after seeing the tribunals keep one case after another CAV for months.
He said the tribunal had needed time to prepare the verdicts because the prosecution was not very competent.
“I do not want to think that the tribunals are unnecessarily taking time for passing the verdicts. We cannot say anything against this [Awami League] government because the opponent [BNP-Jamaat alliance] will not continue the trial as the accused are mostly from Jamaat,” he said.
With an overwhelming mandate to try the war criminals, the Awami League government started the trial in March 2010 during its previous term.
So far, trials of nine war criminals – three in the first International Crimes Tribunal and six in the second – have been completed.