Slow progress in cases against BCI, Rid Pharma

Trials of two cases filed for manufacturing adulterated paracetamol syrups that caused deaths of many children have been delayed at the Dhaka Drug Court since the witnesses do not appear for giving deposition.

Another case has remained stalled following a stay order put by High Court.

A Dhaka drug court on Tuesday handed down verdict in one case filed for manufacturing adulterated paracetamol syrups that killed at least 76 children in early the 1990s.

Court sources said hearing date in the case against BCI Pharmaceutical Ltd was deferred 20 times as none of the six witnesses gave their depositions.

Court officer (Peshkar) Rafiqul Islam said: “The witnesses are not coming to the court though it issued arrest warrants against them. This is delaying the trial.”

The case was filed on November 30, 1992 by then drug superintendent Abul Khayer Chowdhury against six top officials. The accused are directors Shajahan Sarker, Shamsul Haque and Nurun Nahar; Executive Director ASM Badruddoza Chowdhury, Production Manager Md Tajul Haque and Quality Control Manager Ayesha Khatun.

Charges against the accused were placed on January 2, 1993 and they were indicted on August 2, 1994.

But the case was subsequently stalled until 2011 following a defence petition filed with the High Court. The court on February 20, 2011 ordered to start trial in the case.

Of the accused, only Shajahan is on bail while the five others have been on the run since the case filed. Police are yet to arrest the accused.

The Dhaka Drug Court on Tuesday sentenced three people of Adflame Pharmaceuticals to 10-year rigorous imprisonment and acquitted two others.

The other companies accused of producing adulterated paracetamol syrups are Rid Pharmaceutical Company and Polychem Laboratories Ltd. The fifth company - City Chemical and Pharmaceutical Works Ltd – was not sued reportedly for having close connection with the then ruling BNP-Jamaat government.

The case against five officials of Rid Pharma has also been delayed due to no-appearance of two out of four witnesses. It was filed for the deaths of at least 28 children across the country due to kidney failure between June and August 2009.

Following this, the Drug Administration sealed off its factory on July 22. The government also formed a seven-member probe committee to investigate the incident.

On July 29, the probe committee announced that they had found poisonous diethylene glycol in the syrups. Rid Pharma used the substance as a substitute for propylene glycol to cut production costs.

The government then banned two drugs of Rid Pharma – Ridaplex (vitamin B-complex syrup) and Temset (paracetamol suspension).

The case was filed on July 21, 2009 by Shafiqul Islam, the drug superintendent, with the Dhaka Drug Court accusing five officials of Rid Pharma. They are Managing Director Mizanur Rahman; directors Sheuli Rahman – also Mizanur’s wife, and Abdul Gani; and pharmacists Mahbubul Islam and Enamul Haque.

Of them, Mizanur and Sheuli are on bail, while the three others are fugitive.

Charges against the accused were framed on March 9, 2011. The investigation officer mentioned four people as prosecution witnesses.

So far, only two witnesses gave their depositions. August 21 has been fixed for the recording deposition of the next witness. This case too has been delayed several times due to non-appearance of witnesses on time.

Public prosecutor Shaheen Ahmed Khan told the Dhaka Tribune: “Though the trial process is underway slowly, we are hopeful about completion of the trial within a short time.”

The case against officials of Polychem Polychem Laboratories Ltd has been remained pending since the High Court stayed its proceedings.