RAB is beyond reform and should therefore be disbanded, Human Rights Watch has said in a letter to Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina.
The New York-based rights organisation also recommended the withdrawal of all army officers from Rapid Action Battalion so it can be transformed into a civilian force before being disbanded.
In the letter, Brad Adams, executive director of HRW’s Asia Division, yesterday wrote: “Although RAB is officially led by a senior police officer, in practice it is run by the military officers who act as his deputies.”
Adams claimed police officers working in RAB “privately complain” of being treated as subservient to the military. He however did not give any instance.
The RAB structure allowed men from the army to participate in securing civilians “without proper training or civilian accountability and oversight,” he said. The Ruling Awami League raised these points when it was in opposition, he claimed.
However, snuffing out the allegations, RAB turned the table on HRW asking it to concentrate on Israel’s offensive in Gaza against Hamas militants, where until yesterday, at least 501 people had died.
“Hundreds of innocent people have been killed by Israel there. The Human Right Watch should concentrate on that issue. It is more urgent than talking about RAB, which is a country’s internal issue,” said Col Ziaul Ahsan, additional director general of the force.
Brad Adams said the elite police unit had been “allowed to operate with impunity by all successive governments” ever since its inception.
He, however, viewed BNP Chairperson Khaleda Zia’s “endorsement of HRW’s recommendation to disband RAB” as a major turning point as the elite force was established by her government.
“Independent organisations estimate that RAB has been responsible for approximately 800 killings over the past 10 years,” Adams said without specifying which organisations he was referring to.
He also said senior government officials including former law minister Shafique Ahmed and Shipping Minister Shahjahan Khan had ignore extrajudicial killings by RAB, terming them “necessary for crime control.”
The letter also mentioned the alleged involvement of RAB officers in the abductions and murders of seven people including Naryanganj panel mayor Nazrul Islam which had plummeted RAB’s public image “to an all-time-low.”
Former RAB 11 chief Lt Col Tarek Sayeed, Maj Arif Hossain and Lt Commander MM Rana were removed from their units after the bodies of the seven people were found floating in Shitalakhyya River in April. After arrest, they admitted their involvements.
In their confessional statements, the dismissed officials mentioned that they followed the orders of a “RAB high up named Zia.”
Following the developments, RAB decided to stay away from tasks outside its core duties. It returned to patrolling the streets two days into Ramadan.
HRW welcomed the probe but said Sheikh Hasina had utterly failed to keep her promise to “hold RAB accountable and prevent future killings.”
The prime minister ruled out disbanding the elite force after the Narayanganj killings and defended its record instead, it said.
Hasina on May 31 dismissed Khaleda’s call for disbanding RAB, saying the institution could not be shut down all of a sudden.
State minister for Home Asaduzzaman Khan also said “disbanding RAB was out of the question.”
HRW calls RAB death squad
Claiming to have investigate several cases, HRW said: “RAB has acted alone or in joint forces with police and BGB to ‘execute’ opposition activists before the January election.
“Authorities in multiple cases have admitted that these men were shot in custody or during encounters.”
HRW claimed to have probed at least 10 cases of illegal arrests by men who identified themselves as RAB and found that victims, who were taken away on RAB vehicles, ended up being dead and their bodies were dumped on the side of the road.
“These cases and others are the reason Human Rights Watch calls RAB a death squad,” the letter said.
“HRW is aware that Bangladesh needs ‘strong law enforcement agencies’ but RAB is beyond reforms because of its long involvement in ‘systematic killings’,” Adams said.
RAB denies HRW’s allegations
Denying HRW’s allegation, RAB ADG Col Ziaul Ahsan said: “The RAB has never never been involved in any extrajudicial killing. Since the beginning, RAB has been working to curb crime and it will continue doing so.
“There is a government body designated to punish the offenders in law enforcement agencies. Moreover, there are many instances in which we have taken departmental actions following internal investigations.
“There is nothing called extrajudicial killing in RAB. The government will look after the matter,” the colonel said.