Specific bench needed for quick disposal of rules

Innumerable rules issued by the High Court on various matters including public interest litigations are not disposed of as there is no specific bench to conduct the final hearings, legal professionals have said.

Sufferings of justice seekers will minimise to some extent if the chief justice fixes four to five benches comprising skilled judges to administer the final hearings.

Apart from lack of specific bench, changes in jurisdiction of a bench concerned and “unwillingness” of judges are the other reasons for delay and non-disposal of the rules, according to the lawyers dealing with such matters.

The HC from 2006 to date issued at least four rules seeking explanations from the government on extra-judicial killings. But no final hearings have been held let alone disposed of.

When asked, Attorney General Mahbubey Alam told the Dhaka Tribune that he had to ask the government lawyers concerned whether replies were given in response to the rules. 

Only disposal of rules could not stop such killings unless the total situation was developed. “All through I have expressed my view against extrajudicial killings. But at the same time, I expressed my anxiety regarding the protection of life and property of the innocent citizens.

“We have to think how we can effectively control the miscreants and ensure safety of the people,” he said.

On July 29, 2012, the HC asked the government to explain in six weeks why the law – which gives indemnity to “Operation Clean Heart” conducted jointly by the armed forces, police and paramilitary forces – should not be held unconstitutional.

During the BNP-Jamaat coalition regime, the joint operation was conducted between October 16, 2002 and January 9, 2003 when at least 60 people were killed, according to New York-based Human Rights Watch.

Hearing on the rule has not been taken place.

Md Nazrul Islam, an official of the Solicitor’s office that deals with the cases involving the government, told the Dhaka Tribune that the response had not been submitted yet.

The HC on June 29, 2009 issued another rule asking the government as to why the extra-judicial killings, in the name of “crossfire” or “encounter” should not be held illegal. The rule came up in response to a writ plea filed jointly by Ain O Salish Kendra (ASK), Bangladesh Legal Aid and Services Trust (BLAST) and Karmojibi Nari.

Abonti Nurul, lawyer for ASK, told the Dhaka Tribune that though they had made several attempts, the benches were “unwilling” to hear the matter.

According to ASK, at least 46 people were killed in “gunfights” by the law enforcement agencies from January 1 to February 16. Such killings first surfaced in 2004, after the formation of the elite force RAB (Rapid Action Battalion).

Supreme Court lawyer Jyotirmoy Barua told the Dhaka Tribune that the stipulated time to respond to a rule was not mandatory, rather a formality.

After obtaining a rule, the petitioner has to serve the copy and order of the plea to the respondents. Next, he has to inform the court on service of notice so that a date can be fixed to begin the final hearing.

“The main problem is that there is no specific bench which can only deal with hearings on the rules. As a result, hearings are not generally held within three years of the issuance of a rule. However, if a matter is urgent having public interest, it is disposed of earlier.

“Moreover, the judges also do not get enough time to hear the [pending] rules as the benches have to hear new cases and applications of the earlier cases,” he said.

The HC on May 25, 2006 issued a rule on killing Tunda, who was identified as a terrorist, in response to a writ petition seeking explanation from the government as to why it should not be directed to ensure safety of those detained by the law enforcers.

Human Rights and Peace for Bangladesh filed the petition. Lawyer Manzill Murshid, president of the organisation, told the Dhaka Tribune that though he had taken initiatives several times for a final hearing on the rule, it did not take place due to change in jurisdiction of the bench concerned.

“The matter appeared on the cause list many times, but was not heard,” he said.

The government could place its response at the final hearing. However, had they replied earlier, much information would have been revealed, the lawyer said.