The High Court has held that the condition of passing separately in each of the three parts – creative, objective and practical – of Physics, Chemistry and Biology in HSC is illegal.
The bench of Justice Quazi Reza-Ul Hoque and Justice ABM Altaf Hossain delivered the judgement in response to a writ petition filed by an HSC examinee Farah Tasnim Raisa of Dhaka City College.
Shah Mohammad Ahsanur Rahman, lawyer of the petitioner, told the Dhaka Tribune that on March 18 he got the certified copy of the full text of the judgement of January 29.
Raisa in her plea said in 2013 HSC exams, she obtained A+ in three subjects and A in two, but she did not pass in Chemistry as the new system provisioned for passing separately in each of the three parts – objective having 35 marks, creative 40 marks and practical 25 marks.
The Dhaka Board also denied her application of re-evaluation of the Chemistry answer script.
The High Court in its judgement directed the board to re-evaluate her Chemistry answer script and observed that the board had not any authority to destroy the career of any students.
Though the ruling was passed following an individual writ plea, the authorities concerned would not be able to continue with such exam system in HSC in future as it was introduced in violation of the Intermediate and Secondary Education Board Ordinance, 1961, Ahsanur Rahman said.
He said other students would reap the benefit of the judgment if they came to the court regarding other subjects in which the conditions were same as no gazette notification was issued on the matter.
Earlier on October 7, 2013, the HC issued a rule, asking why dividing the science papers – Physics, Chemistry and Biology – into the three parts in the HSC examination 2013, and imposing undeclared condition on passing separately in each of the three parts in violation of the said law should not be held illegal.
In the rule, the court also wanted to know why the respondents concerned should not be directed to re-examine the petitioner’s answer scripts and accordingly publish the re-evaluated result of the petitioner.