The High Court is set to deliver verdict tomorrow on the contempt of court charge against Bengali daily the Prothom Alo for publishing column criticising anticipatory bails.
The bench of Justice Naima Haider and Justice Zafar Ahmed fixed the day ending the hearing when Mizanur Rahman Khan, joint editor of the daily, said he apologised if the judges had been hurt by his column, which criticised the anticipatory bails granted by the bench.
Editor Matiur Rahman said he could not evade the responsibility of publishing a column on his newspaper though it was an opinion, not a news report.
“As we have to publish 24-32 page paper every day, it is not possible to analyse each and every word. So, mistakes can be seen in the paper which does not mean that we intend to demean the court,” he said.
After reading Matiur’s written reply, the judge said: “You got anticipatory bail from the High Court earlier. So what is your opinion on that type of bail for which Mizanur criticised us?”
Matiur said anticipatory bail was very much essential as there was apprehension that the lower court might not grant bail whereas the High Court had the right to give bail.
Following a plea by Prothom Alo counsel Shahdin Malik the court provided Mizanur a chair in the dock. He had to remain standing in the dock during the half-day hearing on Monday.
Shahdin made submission on the legal points. The bench then asked Matiur Rahman to place his arguments on some points.
Justice Naima asked Matiur whether he read the column of Mizanur. The editor said he read the article before and after its publication. “Mistakes can be there in the paper but it was not intentional and not to demean the court.”
Justice Naima said: “As many international dailies specify that they will not be liable for any views, then who is the responsible for the column?” In reply, Matiur said as the editor of the daily, he incurred the responsibility for its publication.
Then the judge said it was clear that the article was written against this specific bench. “We also say judges are like wives of Julius Caesar, the king of Rome, so not above suspicion. So we may be criticised but that should not be based on distorted facts which was done in the column of Mizanur.”
Matiur then said they had no intention to debase the court. Justice Naima said: “You should have been very cautious about publishing such article.”
The journalist in reply to another question of the bench said: “We have Press Council for regulating the press but the institution should be made stronger. We also have Press Act and code of conduct.”
In reply to a question of the court, Shahdin said if the journalists had revealed the source of their news, they would not do journalism since nobody would talk to them. He termed media “the fourth pillar of the state.”
At one point of his submission, pro-BNP lawyer Zainul Abedin requested him to clear whether Mizanur contested the case or sought apology.
Justice Naima conceded with Zainul. Then Shahdin consulted with Mizanur who told the court that he did not have any intention to demean the court rather he had the objective to reform the institution.
“Even after that, if the court thinks that any word or any portion has any indication to hurt the court, I apologise,” Mizanur told the bench.
Then Rokanuddin Mahmud, who argued against Mizanur, said as the newspaper’s editor made his position clear the charge against him could be dropped and the hearing could be closed for judgement.
He pleaded that as the High Court had directives in appointing judges, the bench could give guidelines on how to report on the matters of the Supreme Court.
Justice Naima asked Shahdin to assist the court regarding formulation of guidelines for journalists. Later, the bench fixed Thursday for judgement and said those who gave statement against Rokan for his comments during hearing would have to appear in person today.