Contradictions in existing laws are depriving rape victims from getting the best possible justice amid longstanding demand from rights activists to ensure capital punishment for the crime.
In the Code of Criminal Procedure, better known as the penal code, although there is a provision for life term imprisonment for committing rape, there are also mentions of other terms of up to 10 years.
According to the specialised Women and Children Repression Prevention Act, coined in 2000 to speed up the trial of rape cases and ensure justice for women, the highest punishment for rape is death sentence.
However, for awarding death sentence, a court has to be convinced that the victim has died because she was raped or injured from “gang rape.”
On Thursday, a court in Manikganj sentenced two men to life-term imprisonment for raping an 18-year old garment factory worker in a running bus in Savar near Dhaka.
Recently, two special tribunals in Chittagong and Bogra sentenced seven people to life term imprisonment for abducting and raping three girls. In Chittagong, the Women and Children Repression Prevention Tribunal 1 found three people guilty of abducting two girls and gang-raping them in 2011 and sentenced them to life in prison.
Lawyers, however, said these were just exceptions. In most other cases filed in connection with rapes and attempted rapes, the victims were deprived of justice, mainly because the cases were filed under the penal code, the less strict law towards rape.
Prakash Ranjan Biswas, a lower court practitioner, told the Dhaka Tribune: “In our country, justice cannot always be ensured because of ignorance about existing laws. The police stations often encourage or suggest the complainants to file cases under the penal code instead of the specialised Women and Children Repression Prevention Act. As a result, the court cannot always ensure the highest punishment for such crimes.”
Sources said sometimes the police stations mediated understanding between the victim and the accused. There had been instances where the victim or her family decided to not file a case after getting meagre compensation from the rapist.
In November last year, two alleged rapists were arrested by police in a village in Faridpur district. Police, however, later freed the two. The local Union Parishad chairman said the duo paid Tk20,000 to the family of the housewife, whom they had allegedly raped. Local police claimed that nobody had come to file any case.
In May last year, a man forcefully entered a house in the capital’s Badda and allegedly raped a woman. Police picked up the alleged rapist from that very house. However, a few days later, the alleged rapist, with strong political connections, secured bail and started threatening the family of the girl to withdraw the case filed again him. He has never been put behind bars again and the woman and her husband have since been struggling for justice.
Lawyers say life term is not enough as punishment for heinous crimes such as raping. They also allege that weak investigation, incorrect police report, and failure of prosecutors and police officers to present strong cases before criminal courts are vital reasons behind low conviction rate in rape cases.
The 2013 annual report of rights body Ain O Salis Kendra mentioned a total of 813 reported rape incidents and 185 attempted rapes. Among those, 287 victims were minor girls, of whom 188 were less than 12 years old. Some 256 were gang rapes.
However, only about 550 cases were filed in connection with all those rapes and attempted rapes. Moreover, most of these cases have remained in the shelves because the prosecutions could not find enough witnesses.
Women’s rights activist Salma Khan, former chairman of the international Cedow committee, said: “Violence against women is the extreme form of prejudice where men often go unpunished. If we can ensure real punishment, then the circumstances will never encourage other people to commit the crime.”
She alleged that police did of not record cases properly and as a result, the accused often got away with minimum punishment.