The term “Hartal” is not a new phenomenon in Bangladesh. Every one living in Bangladesh is well introduced to the facts and facets of hartal. The term has got so much momentum that some English dictionaries put the word in their dictionary though the word is a Gujrati one. For example, as per Merriam-Webster dictionary hartal means a concerted cessation of work and business especially as a protest against a political situation or an act of government. The Macmillan dictionary also defines it as an occasion when shops are closed and people stop working as a political protest.
From the historical point of view, hartal acquires an importance when the interest of the society at large come under attack of an autocrat. The early 1950s to 1970s remind us that hartal was called because of the overriding united aspiration of the nation to send a message to the illegitimate dictatorial regime. It was an acceptable means of showing dissent when constitutional politics diminished, when illegitimacy was the basic component on which a group of people attempt to undermine the democratic environment of the republic.
It was a protest through nonviolence and non-cooperation by the masses. It was not reported anywhere in the history that any person was harassed or victimised by the party calling hartal in those days. In the year 1997 the term “bandh” (strike) for the very first time came into the Indian Court premises for identifying its constitutional validity. The Indian Supreme Court in Bharat Kumar v State of Kerala (AIR, 1997) held that “bandh”, which is accompanied by the threat and use of force has not been treated as a part of the freedom of expression. That means if a “bandh” is observed peacefully without threat and use of force it comes within the scope of freedom of expression as well as constitutional validity.
After the elapsing of three years from the date of the Bharat Kumar case the Supreme Court of Bangladesh also faced the similar question whether hartal is a constitutional right, and falls within the scope of freedom of expression. The Honourable High Court Division in Khondaker Modarresh Elahi v Bangladesh (BLD, 2001) held that calling for hartal not accompanied by threat and use force is only an expression guaranteed as a fundamental right under the constitution.
The High Court Division, in the same case, also emphasised that any attempt to enforce the hartal interfering with an individual’s right would render the call illegal, and not protected under the constitution. The High Court Division also observed that it is a democratic right to call hartal, but it should be observed peacefully without resorting to any illegal activities by the pro-hartal activists, but at the same time, hartal should also be allowed to be observed peacefully without any provocation, instigation, intervention, and aggression of any kind by anti-hartal activists.”
However, the total hartal scenario in the present day cannot be termed as peaceful or without the threat or use of force. At present, any person can be a victim of hartal violence. After observing the recent hartals and its consequence, no one who has a minimum sense of humanity can justify hartal as a fundamental right or freedom of expression, rather it can be termed as freedom of oppression. Torching human beings in the name of hartal cannot be termed as a citizen protest against tyrants.
Recent violence during hartal is so precarious that the term threat or use of force is not enough to describe the actual situation. In Abdul Mannan Bhuiyan v the State (DLR, 2008) the Appellate Division observed that enforcing hartal by force leading to violence, death and damage to the life and property of other citizens, is not only illegal, but also liable to be punished as per law of the land.
Hartal is resorted to and supported by the parties in opposition while it is criticised and opposed by the party in power. But, people in general suffer rather than the parties in power and in the opposition. In the name of freedom of expression, the ordinary people are oppressed. Two parties are fighting for their own interests, resulting a dreadful consequence to ordinary people.
In the last two decades, political parties are calling and claiming hartal as their political right ignoring public interest, health, and life. All the sectors of economic development, ie transport, garment industry, are paralyzed due to the curse of hartal.
Hartal creates a long term impact on savings, financial losses, and reduces productivity in agriculture and businesses. Hartal also imposes non-financial expenses on people, including anxiety and insecurity. The education sector is brought to a standstill due to the continuous hartal program.
Though the Supreme Court of Bangladesh declared hartal as a form of freedom of expression, but in reality it turns into freedom of oppression. However, we urge the political leaders to consider the negative effects of hartal in our national life. We also hope that they will try to avoid hartal and look for alternative ways of protest.
We the citizens of Bangladesh want to see the development of a political culture where respect, civility and dialogue should get preference over hartal and violence. And above all, we hope to see a blissful and affluent Bangladesh where there is no place of hartal violence and a stable political culture will prevail in the country.