Tribunal 1 faces ‘little’ uncertainty

Verdict in the war crimes case against Jamaat-e-Islami chief Motiur Rahman Nizami is likely to be delayed as the International Crimes Tribunal 1 is yet to get a new chairman and the authorities are still undecided regarding whether the closing arguments would be re-heard.

Justice ATM Fazle Kabir of the three-member tribunal kept the case for judgement on November 13. As he went into retirement on Tuesday, everybody has been in puzzle about the case’s fate since then.

The tribunal 1 has already deferred all its proceedings until January 7. From this, it is apparent that the new chairman may be appointed by this time.

When contacted, State Minister for Law Quamrul Islam told the Dhaka Tribune yesterday that they would fill the position within the shortest possible time.

In this baffling situation, the question of further arguments is raised as the new chairman would have to include his/her observation in the verdict. Some prosecutors say there is no reason to hear the arguments again whereas other prosecutors and the defence say any member who joins in the middle of a trial conventionally hears the case again.

If so, then the verdict will come in after much delay.

Yesterday, the judge came to the tribunal and met with his former colleagues. He had a relaxed day.

Tribunal sources said the government was considering extending the job of Justice Kabir. But there is a “technical problem” – the judge is now 67. According to article 96(1) of the constitution, a judge is supposed to retire after he reaches the age of 67 years. He was born on January 1, 1947 in Chapainawabganj.

The government is also weighing on two High Court judges for the position. 

On the issues, Tureen Afroz, a prosecutor who also conducted arguments in the Nizami case, said everything would be smooth had the former chairman been reappointed. “If a new judge is appointed, s/he will peruse both the witness testimonies and the evidences.”

She said, however, for the sake of justice and to come to a just conclusion, the judge would require hearing the arguments of both sides.

The prosecutor noted that the parties are not allowed to place new arguments during resubmissions.

Tajul Islam, defence counsel for Nizami, said the new chairman should hear both parties. “If not, then how will he take any part in the  judgement?”

He added that the defence would submit a plea to re-hear the case, at least the argument part. 

Sources said there was no legal bar to hear the case again if the tribunal wanted. But it is not mandatory. However, the judge might hear a short argument to ensure justice.

“Everything will be settled in a few days. These uncertainties will last for a very short time,” said a tribunal official seeking anonymity.