Landmark judicial decisions on election disputes

‘Right to vote’ is a common law right

Ashby v White was an eighteenth century UK case where the court held that “right to vote” is a common law right and violation of the right calls for damages.

Matthew Ashby, a cobbler, turned up to cast his vote for the British Parliament in December 1701. Ashby was turned away by William White, a constable, on the grounds that “he was no settled inhabitant of the borough, and had never contributed either to the church, or the poor.

In spite of this his candidate won the election and no harm was caused to him. But Ashby refused to take this lying down, and sued for substantial damages. The defendants contended that since Ashby had suffered no loss as his candidate had won the election, he was not liable.

His suit was successful, but the House of Commons found Ashby guilty of a breach of parliamentary privilege for having carried through his action at common law. Chief Justice Holt then upheld Ashby’s appeal, arguing that what was at issue was “a most transcendent thing, and of a high nature.”

Finally it was held that the defendant (White) by preventing the plaintiff (Ashby) from voting violated Ashby’s legal right and was entitled to damages.

Chief Justice Holt said, “Every injury imports a damage though it does not cost the party one farthing. For a damage not merely pecuniary, but an injury imports a damage, when a person is thereby hindered of his rights.”

Choosing ‘None of the Above’ in the fray

The Supreme Court of India, in its judgment dated September 27, 2013, in People’s Union for Civil Liberties and another v the Union of India and another, has directed the election commission to make necessary provision in the ballot papers/EVMs and provide a button for ‘None of the Above’ in EVMs so that the voters who come to the polling booth, and decide not to vote for any of the candidates in the fray, are able to exercise their right not to vote while maintaining their right of secrecy.

In accordance with the order of the Supreme Court “None of the Above” shall be printed in a separate panel on the ballot paper below the name of the last contesting candidate. This ballot paper shall be affixed on the ballot unit of the EVM. If the voter presses the button next to “None of the Above” his desire not to vote for any of the candidates in the fray will get recorded in the EVM in secrecy.

Commission shall also make appropriate changes in Part-2 of Form 17C used during counting and the result sheet in Form 20 to separately compile the number of persons who used the option not to vote for any of the candidates in the fray. Election Commission of India shall issue detailed instructions to ensure compliance with the order of the court as expeditiously as possible.

Voters have a right to know about the candidates

In the judgment of Abdul Momen Chowdhury v Election Commission (2005), the court held that at the heart of parliamentary system is free and fair election; when parliament has made valid laws  related to election, the election commission shall act in conformity with the law, but where there is no law, article 119 which confers on the election commission the responsibility of supervising and controlling the conduct of elections is a reservoir of power to act for the avowed purpose of holding free and fair election.

In order that the voters have a free choice, the must be provided with the material information about the candidates. The court further held that the voters have a right to know about the candidates and such right is included in the right to franchise.

Therefore, the High Court Division of Bangladesh held that the election commission may direct candidates for parliamentary elections to submit the following eight kinds of information:

a)            Academic qualification with certificate from board or university, if possess any qualification

b)            Whether he is accused in any criminal case at present

c)            Whether there was any past record of criminal case and the result

d)            Profession / occupation

e)            Source or sources of income

f)             Whether he was a parliament member earlier and the role he played individually and collectively in fulfilling the commitment to the people

g)            Description of assets and liabilities of the candidate and dependent of the candidate

h)            Particulars and amount of loan taken from bank or financial institutions deals with public money personally, jointly or by dependent or loan taken by the company from bank where the candidate is chairman, or managing director or director etc.