Nerve-racking 38 hours for SC clearance

After around 38 hours of gripping situation since the dramatic halt of Abdul Quader Molla’s execution on Tuesday night, the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court yesterday rejected his review petitions clearing all legal bars to carry out the capital punishment.

“There is no legal bar to implement the apex court verdict,” Attorney General Mahbubey Alam told reporters after pronouncement of the verdict around 12:10pm.

There was pin-drop silence, as if, everyone in the packed courtroom held their breath while Chief Justice Md Muzammel Hossain was pronouncing the decision in a single sentence: “Both the review petitions are dismissed.”

One petition was filed on Wednesday morning to review the death penalty while the other challenged conviction in five other charges.

The five-member bench of the Appellate Division rejected the petitions unanimously after two days of hearing. The bench comprises the chief justice, Justice Surendra Kumar Sinha, Justice Md Abdul Wahhab Miah, Justice Syed Mahmud Hossain and Justice AHM Shamsuddin Choudhury Manik.

Supreme Court Registrar AKM Shamsul Islam told the Dhaka Tribune that they had sent the copy of the order to the jail authorities around 3:20pm and also served the copy to the International Crimes Tribunal 2, the home ministry, the Attorney General’s Office and the defence counsels.

In line with the International Crimes (tribunals) Act 1973, the government ordered to execute Quader Molla, well-known as “Mirpurer Koshai” (Butcher of Mirpur) on Tuesday night for the heinous crimes against humanity he had committed during the 1971 Liberation War. As per the government directives, the prison authorities were all set to implement the verdict and gallows was ready to hang him at 12:01am at that night.

Prison authorities had also arranged family members last meeting with the condemned war criminal at Dhaka Central Jail on Tuesday evening.

Against that backdrop, Molla’s counsels led by Jamaat Assistant Secretary General Abdur Razzak went to the residence of the chamber judge, Justice Syed Mahmud Hossain, to seek a stay order on the execution. The chamber judge had stayed the execution until 10:30am on Wednesday.

When people were waiting for the execution and watching every moment’s developments on Tuesday night, the stay order came as a relief for Quader Molla, his family members, party followers and sympathisers.

On February 5, the International Crimes Tribunal 2 gave him life-term imprisonment in one charge and sentenced to different terms in the five other charges. Following appeals hearing, the five-member top court bench by majority awarded Quader Molla death sentence on September 17 overruling the life-term.

Of the five judges, Justice Wahhab had awarded the war criminal life imprisonment in the sixth charge that deals with the killing of tailor Hazrat Ali and five other members of his family in Mirpur. He acquitted Quader Molla in the five other charges.

However, the remaining four judges gave the war criminal death sentence for the sixth charge and imprisonment of different terms for the others.

Full text of the Appellate Division verdict was released on December 5. On receiving copy of the full text, the tribunal on Sunday issued death warrant to execute the capital punishment.

Arguments at the court

All eyes were on the apex court since Wednesday morning when it began hearing on a petition of Quader Molla to extend the stay order. Razzak, chief counsel for the convict, wanted to begin hearing of the review petition in January, after the winter vacation of the court. The vacation starts today.

But after the judges’ repeated requests, Razzak agreed to begin the hearing that day which continued until 11:47am yesterday with both the sides placing their arguments.

On the first day, both sides argued whether Quader Molla’s review petition was maintainable or not. The attorney general argued that it was not maintainable while the defence sought for accepting the petition.

The second day’s hearing on the review petitions started around 9:15am. In the beginning of the hearing, Razzak wanted to proceed by placing arguments in favour of maintainability of the review petitions. 

But the court asked him to contend why he had challenged the verdict. Razzak replied that he had no preparation to argue on the issue. 

As the court insisted, he said the testimony of Momena Begum in charge six on which the top court gave the death penalty was “not reliable” since she had given three different statements – to Zalladkhana, the investigation officer and at the tribunal – in the case. 

At that time, Justice Sinha said: “We punished Quader Molla since we find Momena’s testimony credible.” 

Razzak said there was error in the judgement for which Justice Wahhab had given different verdict life-term imprisonment. 

Justice Wahhab then told Razzak: “The death sentence was given by four other judges. So, please do not refer me. If you do so, I feel embarrassed.”

The defence counsel said the death warrant issued by the tribunal 2 had not been legal. “As per the jail code, the court that passed the death sentence has to issue the warrant,” Razzak claimed.

Justice Sinha said the Appellate Division had asked the tribunal to communicate with the concerned authorities. Razzak argued that for an execution, the jail code was a must. 

At this point, Justice Wahhab drew the attention of the defence counsel citing section 20 (3) of the tribunal law which states: “The sentence awarded under this Act shall be carried out in accordance with the orders of the government.” 

The chief justice asked Razzak to read section 20(3) with section 26 that say: “The tribunal law shall prevail over other laws.” 

Then Razzak said the tribunal law did not say about the process of hanging a convict. 

In reply, the chief justice said: “Our judgement clearly says how to execute.” The full text of the verdict said Quader Molla be hanged until death. 

Attorney General Mahbubey Alam told the court: “The constitution does not curtail the apex court’s power to review rather it bars the war crimes convicts to move the Supreme Court.

“The court can review the verdict if it wishes to, but not on a petition of a person convicted for crimes against humanity, genocide and war crimes as the constitution does not give that right to such a convict.”

The judges adjourned the proceedings at 11:47am for 15 minutes and left the bench saying they would come back to deliver the verdict.

It was a nerve-racking 15 minutes for the lawyers of both sides, other observers and journalists present at the court, and the people across the country waiting eagerly to know about the final verdict.

The chief justice’s dismissal order made the justice seekers smile after 42 years of independence; though, naturally, it was a huge disappointment for the defence.

Agitated by the order, pro-BNP-Jamaat lawyers brought out a procession in front of the bar association building. They chanted slogans: “Don’t worry Quader Molla as we did not leave streets,” “Every house will be burnt, if anything happens to Quader Molla,” “Lawyers’ action, direct action.” 

They also chanted slogans against the government and Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina asking her to step down right away.

In the meantime, another group of lawyers including pro-Awami League groups who were happy with the decision also chanted slogans and brought out a procession at the same place. 

There was tension for a while on the court premises centring the two groups’ procession at the same time. A scuffle also took place between several rival lawyers.

The law enforcement agencies yesterday were on tight vigil in the court area as they deployed more than 500 members of different forces. 

But violence sparked outside the capital as Jamaat and its student wing Islami Chhatra Shibir men attacked police, vehicles and installations, and vandalised or torched those, leaving several people hilled and a number of people injured.