Death for absconding al-Badr operatives

Many in the courtroom, mostly family members of martyred intellectuals, broke down in tears on Sunday when the war crimes tribunal handed down death sentences to notorious al-Badr leaders Chowdhury Mueen Uddin and Ashrafuzzaman Khan for their leading roles in the killing of intellectuals in 1971.

The three-member tribunal 2 termed the killings “elitocide” – a systematic killing of a community’s political and economic leadership so that it could not regenerate.

Anticipating certain defeat, the Pakistani occupation forces and their collaborators – razakar, al-Badr and al-Shams (formed mostly with leaders of Jamaat-e-Islami and its then student front, Islami Chhatra Shangha) – had abducted leading Bangalee intellectuals and professionals prior to the declaration of victory on December 16, 1971 and killed them en masse with a view to crippling the nation intellectually.

Since then, the nation every year observes the Martyred Intellectuals Day on December 14.

The victims’ relatives, friends, well-wishers and millions of justice seekers have long waited for the day of the verdict. When it came on Sunday, 42 years after the horrific incidents, the emotionally choked near and dear ones of the martyred intellectuals cried out in joy and embraced each other.

“There are some tearful moments that are involved with victory,” Prof Anirban Mostafa, son of a martyred intellectual, told the Dhaka Tribune after the pronouncement of the verdict.

“I think Bangladesh was waiting for this day,” said Anirban, who was only nine months old when his father, journalist ANM Golam Mostafa, was abducted by al-Badr members on the instruction of Mueen and Ashraf.

Martyred Mostafa was the chief reporter of the national daily Purbadesh in 1971, where Mueen worked as a staff reporter. Anirban, a professor of the architecture department at Khulna University, came to the tribunal along with his wife Afroza Parvin and 10-year-old son Bishonko Broto. Mostafa never came back, like many other abducted intellectuals who had been picked up by the armed gangs of al-Badr.

The war crimes case against the duo is popularly known as the intellectual killing case, since all the 11 charges brought against them were for abduction and killing of 18 intellectuals that had taken place between December 10 and 15 of 1971.

“The events were chained together and were perpetrated by a group of al-Badr men forming a killing squad to which Chowdhury Mueen Uddin was the operation-in-charge and Ashrafuzzaman Khan was the chief executor,” said the judgement.

The tribunal of Chairman Justice Obaidul Hassan and members Justice Md Mozibur Rahman Miah and Justice Md Shahinur Islam pronounced the summary of the 154-page verdict in a packed courtroom, which was only slightly less crowded than other verdict days.

Regular followers of the trials of war crimes cases observed that the reduced attendance might be due to the trial in absentia, with Mueen believed to be living in the UK and Ashraf in the USA.

The judges unanimously found Mueen and Ashraf guilty of all the 11 charges and condemned them to the single sentence of death, as per the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act.

“They will be hanged by the neck till they are dead,” said the verdict, adding that since the convicted accused had been absconding, their sentence shall be executed either after arresting them or when they surrendered before the tribunal.

The judges cited records from local and foreign newspapers, a British documentary, books on the 1971 Liberation War by local and foreign authors and testimonies of witnesses to draw their conclusion.

“We have unerringly concluded that al-Badr being backed by its creator Jamaat-e-Islami and Pakistani occupation army designed a premeditated and secret plan to exterminate the best and notable intellectuals belonging to different professions,” said the verdict. “The intention was to make the nation paralysed.

“It was simply an ‘elitocide’ accomplished in furtherance of a calculated policy and plan. The event of calculative killing of intellectuals in 1971 will forever torment the Bangalee nation.”

The verdict said: “The fierceness of the event of the ‘intellectuals killing’ was extremely detrimental to basic humanness. It deserves to be evaluated as ‘crimes of serious gravity’ intending to demean the human civilisation.”

It said Mueen and Ashraf “were actively concerned in committing crimes against humanity, by aiding, abetting, instructing, ordering, encouraging and providing moral support to the members of al-Badr” and as members of its high command, they “had de facto reasonable and material ability and authority to control” al-Badr.

Citing history, the judges viewed: “The humankind experienced enormous atrocious attack directing civilian population in many parts of the world. But it has never crossed through experiencing the heartrending event of massive killing targeting a ‘group’ belonging to intellectual community known as the ‘conscience’ of a nation.”

The verdict said the intellectual killing case was “such type of unheard of extermination committed in execution of designed murderous scheme. It not only increases the magnitude of the crimes but it has imprinted untold trauma to the nation.”

“Letters of law cannot remain non-reactive to the enormous colossal and unspeakable pains being carried for decades together by the relatives of martyred intellectuals and the nation too.”

The verdict said: “The designed plan, pattern of such selective but large scale killing of intellectuals inescapably aggravated the magnitude of the criminal acts and liability of the accused persons as well.”

The judges said the martyred intellectuals had been the distinguished sons and daughters of the land bearing untainted pro-liberation ideology. “They could have immensely contributed in building the nation if they had not been eliminated.”

Thus it is proved that al-Badr was deployed in furtherance of “organised master plan” designed by the fascist Jamaat-e-Islami to wipe out the “socio-cultural intellectual” group of Bangladesh with intent to paralyse the Bangalee nation.

Quoting from the book “Sunset at Midday” by Mohiuddin Chowdhury, the verdict said: “Al-Badr acted as a ‘killing squad’ of Jamaat in accomplishing the plan. Al-Badr, a paramilitary force, was formed by the leaders of ICS [Islami Chhatra Sangha], the student wing of Jamaat. It was formed purely of workers of ICS.”

Activities of al-Badr had been carried out under the control and co-ordination of Jamaat, the judgement said.

Citing a few reports published in a Bangla newspaper in 1971, it said: “We believe that the nation shall be continuing to pay its humble tribute and reverence to the martyred intellectuals by reiterating the homage…also with a pledge to struggle the recurrence of impious clout in the days to come.”

Educationists Shyamoli Nasrin Chowdhury, wife of martyred Abdul Alim Chowdhury, and Prof Anirban, son of martyred ANM Golam Mostafa were seen continuously wiping off tears. Anirban’s son, 10-year-old Bishonko, also broke into tears. He has grown up learning the history of the country’s Liberation War.

Bishonko said he learnt from his father, mother and other relatives about the Liberation War’s history, and the sacrifice of his grandfather, other intellectuals and the 3 million martyrs of the country.

“We read in school about their sacrifice,” Bishonko told the Dhaka Tribune.

Martyred intellectual Giasuddin Ahmed’s sisters, brother and a niece also came to the tribunal. They expressed satisfaction over the verdict as at least they could see the judgement of the intellectual killing being delivered.

“We want to see the verdict implemented after bringing back the convicts to the country,” said Prof Hamida Banu, a sister of Giasuddin.