'Constitutional rights not violated'

The war crimes tribunal did not violate the constitution by trying Abdul Alim for war crimes, even though he was made accused under the Collaborators Order 1972, as the character of offences were not same.

Article 35(2) states that no person shall be prosecuted and punished for the same offence more than once. This is why Alim was not allowed to have the “shield of constitutional rights,” the tribunal said.

“We are in unmistaken disposition that the accused cannot have the shield of the principle of double jeopardy as enshrined in article 35(2) of the constitution...it will be incorrect to interpret that double jeopardy does occur even if a person is said to have been prosecuted further for the ‘same offence’ if it is found that he was mere prosecuted and in the end not tried and punished,” said the tribunal 2 led by Justice Obaidul Hassan.

None of the defence documents proved that the trial against Alim under the 1972 order was prosecuted until its last step, the judgement said.

The defence counsels referred to this article during placing their closing arguments and said Alim could not be tried for the same offence under the International Crimes (Tribunals) Act, 1973.

In response to the defence arguments, the tribunal observed that the offences mentioned in the 1972 order and those mentioned in the ICT Act were not the same.

“The Act of 1973 was enacted to prosecute and try the ‘crimes against humanity,’ ‘genocide’ and other ‘system crimes’...There is no scope to characterise the offences underlying in the Collaborators Order 1972 to be the ‘same offences’ as specified in the Act of 1973,” the tribunal said.

The judgement also said this was the first case in which a person accused face trail “remaining on bail” and added the trial was carried on “without violating the common law double jeopardy prohibition.”

Legal principle of “double jeopardy” mainly protects one from the jeopardy of punishment by the state twice for the “same offence.”

Alim, now aged 83, was arrested on March 27, 2011 and was enjoying bail throughout the trial process that began on July 5 last year.

He was granted bail since he was confined to a wheelchair and required assistance of two persons to move about.

The tribunal rejected the bail on September 22 when the case was kept for verdict.