The High Court today is set to deliver its verdict on whether eight provisions of the Contempt of Courts Act, 2013, including one involving media reports on the court proceedings, is constitutional or not.
The bench of Justice Quazi Reza-Ul Hoque and Justice ABM Altaf Hossain set the date after hearing both the sides and Dr Kamal Hossain. The matter was kept on top of on Thursday’s cause list.
In response to a petition, a High Court bench on April 3 issued a rule, asking the government to explain why the provisions should not be declared unconstitutional for allegedly curtailing the court’s authority. The petition was moved by lawyer Manzill Murshid. Secretaries to the Cabinet Division, president’s office, Prime Minister’s Office, law ministry, and parliament secretariat were made respondents to the rule.
Filed by lawyers Asaduzzaman Siddiqui and Ayesha Khatun, the petition challenged sections 4-7, 9-11 and 13(2) of the law. The Act was enacted on February 22 this year, replacing the old law of 1926.
Section 5 of the law stipulates that publishing “objective and unbiased reports” on court proceedings should not be subject to contempt. However, Manzill on Wednesday told the court that they had not wanted the freedom of journalists curtailed.
Section 7 states that publication of any unbiased and objective news on any proceedings conducted in the chamber of a judge or “camera trial” shall also not constitute contempt, unless the court imposes a bar.
According to Section 10, if an act is done by a public servant “with a good faith” following the existing laws, it shall not be considered as contempt of court. No contempt charge can be brought against him if he tries properly to implement the judgement, order or directive of the court, but failed.
Taking part in the hearing, Dr Kamal questioned the maintainability of the petition and said it had not elaborated the reasons why it challenged the law.
During the hearing, Justice Quazi Reza said if any act or report was published on an individual judge without the intention of harming the image of the court, it was not contempt. “But if it is done for impairing the court, then the act or report is contempt,” he observed.